Will British Jewry Be Unrecognizable – Or Highly Recognizable – by 2040?

British Jews are increasingly questioning whether they have a future in Britain. Yet by 2040, Britain could have more Jews than it does today.

The apparent contradiction reflects a demographic transformation already underway. One segment of British Jewry is growing rapidly, while another has barely grown in two decades and is increasingly questioning whether to remain.

In 2001, Haredi Jews represented roughly one in eight Jews in England and Wales. By 2021, they accounted for nearly one in four. Today, they represent approximately 26% of Britain’s estimated 315,000 Jews (0.4% – 0.5% of the total UK population). The Haredi population nearly doubled in twenty years, while the rest of British Jewry remained virtually unchanged.

England and Wales20012021
Haredi Jews37,00073,000
Other Jews239,000237,000
Haredi share13%24%

The difference is largely explained by children. Haredi families commonly have five, six or more, and their communities are exceptionally young. Today, 60% of pupils attending British Jewish schools are in strictly Orthodox schools. Those children will become the next generation of parents, carrying forward a demographic expansion already embedded in the population.

While Haredi families are raising the next generation of British Jews, growing numbers of other British Jews are questioning whether to raise theirs in Britain at all.

Haredi Jews in the UK

A December 2025 survey by the Campaign Against Antisemitism found that 61% of respondents had considered leaving Britain because of antisemitism. Only 23% believed Jews had a long-term future in the country. The survey relied on self-selected respondents, but the depth of concern among those surveyed is difficult to dismiss.

Separate research by the Institute for Jewish Policy Research found that approximately 6% of British Jews surveyed in 2024 considered themselves highly likely to move permanently to Israel within five years. More recent JPR research found that younger Jews, Orthodox Jews and those most affected by antisemitism were particularly likely to consider aliyah.

And some are already leaving.

British aliyah to Israel has averaged roughly 550 people annually over the past two decades. In calendar 2025, 742 made aliyah, the highest annual total in more than forty years. During the Jewish year ending in 2026, Israeli authorities reported 975 immigrants from Britain, another forty-year high.

Those numbers represent a small percentage of the country’s Jews (0.3%) and a sustained exodus has not yet been established. Nevertheless, the latest figures suggest that growing emigration concerns may be beginning to translate into action.

Israel is only one destination. British Jews also have family, professional and communal ties to the United States, Canada, Australia and elsewhere. Those departures are harder to count because immigration records in those countries generally do not identify religion.

Nor would it take a mass departure to change British Jewry. A net decline of just 10% of today’s approximately 233,000 non-Haredi Jews over the next fourteen years would represent 23,300 people, equivalent to fewer than 1,700 annually. With historical Haredi growth continuing, that alone would raise the projected Haredi share in 2040 from approximately 36% to nearly 39%.

But the most intriguing twist comes from Israel itself.

For British Jews alarmed by antisemitism, Israel offers a Jewish homeland where they can build a future without depending on the tolerance of a non-Jewish majority. For some Haredi families, however, Israel presents a different calculation.

The Jewish state is struggling over compulsory military service for Haredi men. Israel’s Supreme Court has ruled against the continuation of broad exemptions without legal authorization, and the issue remains deeply contested politically. For British Haredi families opposed to conscription, uncertainty about whether their sons might face military obligations could discourage aliyah. The effect would depend on immigrant eligibility rules and future legislation; there is not yet evidence establishing that it is influencing British Haredi migration decisions.

English-speaking ultra-Orthodox rabbis hold an anti-conscription event in Ramat Beit Shemesh, December 22, 2025. (Sam Sokol/Times of Israel)

The irony is striking. Israel may increasingly attract British Jews who fear antisemitism, while its military conscription controversy could discourage some Haredi families from leaving Britain.

Meanwhile, established Haredi communities in UK’s Stamford Hill, Golders Green, Manchester and beyond provide the schools, synagogues and religious institutions needed to sustain large and growing families.

The result could be a growing divergence within British Jewry, with some Jews increasingly looking abroad while its fastest-growing segment has strong reasons to remain.

Qatar’s al Jazeera video on Haredi community in England ignoring COVID regulations

What would that mean by 2040?

The Institute for Jewish Policy Research has suggested that Haredim could approach one-third of British Jewry by 2040. My analysis suggests that the proportion could be higher, with 40% a plausible intermediate outcome rather than necessarily an upper boundary.

Starting with approximately 82,000 Haredi and 233,000 other Jews today, simply extending historical Haredi population growth of 3.5% annually, with no decline in the rest of British Jewry, produces a Haredi share of approximately 36% by 2040. A modest contraction in the non-Haredi population, combined with somewhat faster Haredi expansion, moves the share toward 40%. More pronounced changes could push it closer to 43%.

2040 scenarioHaredi JewsOther JewsHaredi share
Historical continuity133,000233,00036%
Moderate shift140,000220,00039%
Accelerated shift146,000197,00043%
These are illustrative scenarios, not probability-weighted forecasts. The historical case assumes 3.5% annual Haredi growth and a stable non-Haredi population. The moderate case assumes approximately 3.9% Haredi growth and 0.4% annual non-Haredi decline. The accelerated case assumes approximately 4.2% Haredi growth and 1.2% annual non-Haredi decline.

By 2040, Haredim could represent more than two in five British Jews, reshaping the country’s Jewish schools, synagogues, institutions and relationship with Israel.

The transformation requires no mass exodus. But it could accelerate if Jews questioning their future in Britain begin leaving, while Israeli conscription politics discourage some Haredi families from following.

Britain could have more Jews in 2040 than it has today. But the British Jewry behind those numbers may be profoundly different.


Sources

1. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Historical British Jewish demographics

New Trends in the Study of Haredi Culture and Society, demographic analysis, Table 4. Documents Haredi and non-Haredi population estimates for England and Wales in 2001, 2011 and 2021.

2. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Haredi population estimates

Dr. Daniel Staetsky, Haredi Jews around the world: Population trends and estimates, May 2022. Establishes the demographic characteristics and historical growth rates of Haredi populations.

3. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Updated population estimates

JPR presentation, March 2026. Reports a UK core Jewish population of approximately 315,000, including 82,000 Haredi Jews, representing 26%.

4. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Jewish school enrollment

Five interesting facts about Jewish schools in the UK. Reports that 60% of Jewish pupils attending Jewish schools are enrolled in strictly Orthodox schools.

5. Campaign Against Antisemitism — British Jewish attitudes

New polling: Majority of British Jews see no future in UK, December 21, 2025. Survey of 4,490 respondents, including questions about emigration, antisemitism and the future of Jewish life in Britain.

6. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Emigration and aliyah

Dr. Jonathan Boyd, Time to leave the UK? Patterns of Jewish migration to Israel post-October 7, April 20, 2026. Examines annual aliyah figures, historical averages, emigration intentions and migration limitations.

7. Times of Israel — 2026 aliyah figures

Some 20,000 immigrated to Israel since last Rosh Hashanah as Western aliyah rises, September 2026. Reports 975 immigrants from Britain during the Jewish year.

8. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — 2040 British demographic outlook

Dr. Jonathan Boyd, One in seven of all Jews are strictly Orthodox; by 2040, it will be one in five, June 18, 2022. Discusses the expectation that Britain’s Haredi proportion could approach one-third by 2040.

9. Library of Congress — Israeli Haredi conscription

Israel: High Court Imposes Sanctions on Individual Haredi Men Avoiding Draft, July 1, 2026. Summarizes Israeli Supreme Court rulings and enforcement obligations.

10. Israel Democracy Institute — Conscription controversy

Conscription of Haredi Yeshiva Students to the IDF and the Emerging Constitutional Crisis, January 21, 2026. Explains the legal and political conflict surrounding Haredi military service.

11. FirstOneThrough — Independent 2040 demographic scenarios

Author’s calculations using the JPR March 2026 population estimates as the starting point, with compound annual population growth and decline assumptions over fourteen years. These scenarios are independent illustrations, not published JPR forecasts.

Europe’s Erasure of Jewish Jerusalem

Jews were already the majority of Jerusalem’s population since the 1860s, over half a century before the Balfour Declaration and the British Mandate. Even within the Old City, roughly one-quarter of its recorded Ottoman subjects were Jewish in 1900. Their synagogues, schools, homes and religious institutions were woven into Jerusalem’s life long before the modern State of Israel.

Yet for the last two decades, the European Union has spent millions of euros preserving Jerusalem’s so-called “Palestinian heritage,” with no comparable funding identified for Jewish institutions in the Old City.

In 2013, the EU committed €2.4 million to restoring Islamic baths, a madrasa and other historic buildings. It later provided €4.23 million to rehabilitate a Franciscan-owned property for Palestinian housing and community use. In 2019, the EU awarded another €1.18 million to a project explicitly titled “Protecting Islamic and Christian Cultural Heritage in Jerusalem.”

No money has been spent on preserving Jewish heritage. By design.

In 1948, Jordanian forces captured the Jewish Quarter, expelled its Jewish residents and destroyed or desecrated its synagogues. For nineteen years, Jews were barred from entering the Old City. The Hurva Synagogue lay in ruins for decades.

A lone arch stood in the place of the destroyed Hurva Synagogue, until Israel rebuilt it with its own funds in 2010 (photo: First One Through in 1996)

Europe finances the preservation of Jerusalem’s Islamic and Christian heritage while offering no comparable support for the Jewish institutions that survived that destruction at the hands of Arabs.

The issue is not about Israel’s sovereignty. It is the Jewish people’s history, religion and connection to their holiest city.

The EU is not merely taking sides in a territorial dispute. By selectively funding non-Jewish Jerusalem’s heritage, it has become complicit in the erasure of Jews from the historical and cultural identity of their own holiest city.

The Grocery Bill Is Only a Problem When the Money Goes to Jews

Imagine Cenk Uygur filming his grocery-store commercial in Paris.

Man in a suit speaking into a microphone on a brightly lit stage

French families struggle to afford groceries. Violent riots have shaken major cities. Government debt is soaring, public services are strained, and officials insist there is no money for higher wages.

Yet France just committed another $5.5 million to build infrastructure for Palestinian Arabs in Judea and Samaria.

On November 17, as 146,000 demonstrators protested wages and deteriorating services, France pledged €5 million for Palestinian roads, electricity, water and other infrastructure in disputed territory. Just days earlier, Cenk Uygur blamed France’s riots on unaffordability, Israel and Zionists. He has said nothing about France sending money to Palestinian Arabs.

Of course, $5.5 million won’t rescue France’s finances. Neither would eliminating American aid to Israel make groceries affordable. But that never troubled Uygur’s argument.

The problem was never foreign aid. It was aid to Jews.

Screenshot of a post by Cenk Uygur stating, “If Jesus was born in Bethlehem today, he would be a Palestinian.”
Stupidity from the mouth of an antisemite. If my grandmother had wheels she’d be a wagon.

The Game Has Changed

I listened to two podcasts this week. Dan Senor and Mark Halperin discussed the socialist challenge to the Democratic Party. Yossi Klein Halevi and Donniel Hartman discussed Naza, a film accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza that reportedly received a standing ovation lasting nearly 25 minutes.

What struck me was how four intelligent, experienced men struggled to understand movements that no longer accepted their rules of engagement.

Halperin was puzzled that Abdul El-Sayed had not moderated his positions after the midterm elections. How could he expect to accomplish anything without building relationships and cooperating with his colleagues in Washington?

But El-Sayed and the socialist movement have a different ambition. They want to replace the Democratic establishment, not become more effective members of it. Their success is measured by how far they move the party toward their positions, rather than how many colleagues they persuade to join them on individual bills.

Halperin is waiting for El-Sayed to grow into the Democratic Party. El-Sayed wants the Democratic Party to grow into his movement.

The conversation between Halevi and Hartman revealed a similar disconnect. Both men were disturbed by the extraordinary reception for Naza. They questioned its allegations, its presentation of Hamas and the evidence used to condemn Israel’s conduct in Gaza. They approached the film as serious intellectuals, seeking to separate fact from fiction.

But why would an audience applaud for nearly 25 minutes? For anything?

Such enthusiasm is difficult to explain as a careful assessment of military evidence. The film offered something more emotionally satisfying: confirmation of a worldview in which Israel is not simply guilty of particular actions but is fundamentally illegitimate.

The most radical anti-Zionist activists have moved beyond questions of Israeli military conduct. Their accusation of genocide is not confined to the Gaza war. They portray Zionism itself as a colonial and racist enterprise, Israel’s establishment as an original act of ethnic cleansing and the subsequent history of the Jewish state as a continuing campaign against Palestinian Arabs.

Under this worldview, October 7 did not begin a war that Israel was forced to fight. It merely provided another occasion for Israel to reveal its supposedly genocidal character.

As such, no military investigation can answer an accusation that begins with the existence of the Jewish state. No ceasefire can satisfy a movement that regards Zionism itself as the crime.

This presents a particular challenge for the Shalom Hartman Institute.

Hartman has devoted decades to Jewish scholarship, education and the tradition of machloket l’shem shamayim, disagreement for the sake of heaven. Its podcast, For Heaven’s Sake, reflects the belief that serious people can examine competing arguments and emerge with greater understanding.

But that tradition presumes participants recognize one another’s legitimacy. What happens when one side considers the very existence of the Jewish state an offense that no amount of evidence can justify?

Halperin and Senor expect the socialists to learn how to operate within the Democratic Party. Halevi and Hartman expect Israel’s accusers to be persuaded by facts and reason.

They have not recognized that the game itself has changed.

Who Gets to Write the “Nakba”?

CAIR, Teachers’ Unions and the Jewish Homeland in Connecticut Schools

Connecticut wants its public schools to teach Arab and Islamic Studies. With roughly two billion Muslims, more than 50 Muslim-majority countries and territories, and fourteen centuries of civilization, there is an enormous history to explore.

Yet some advocates want the curriculum to teach children that the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 was genocide against Palestinian Arabs, part of the so-called “Nakba.” In doing so, a course about Islamic civilization risks becoming a political campaign against the Jewish state.

In March 2026, Audra King, a professor at Central Connecticut State University and member of the CSU-AAUP faculty union, urged lawmakers to include the “Nakba” in genocide education. She also called for educator unions, along with Muslim, Palestinian and Arab representatives, to participate in developing the curriculum.

Erna Alic, a Trinity College program manager whose family fled Bosnia, similarly urged Connecticut to teach the “Nakba” alongside the Bosnian genocide. That was an actual genocide, not a political smear.

The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) also advocated including the “Nakba” in Arab and Islamic Studies, as did anti-Israel groups like Jewish Voice for Peace, although it did not explicitly characterize the events of 1948 as genocide.

The testimony was submitted in support of HB 5328, which did not itself become law. Connecticut nevertheless enacted a separate provision directing the development of Arab and Islamic Studies resources.

The controversy then moved from what should be taught to who would write the lessons.

A September investigation by Connecticut Centinal, citing State Department of Education records, reported that the curriculum design team included a national CAIR consultant and four educators recommended by CAIR-Connecticut.

Proposed CT teachers for “Nakba” submitted via email from CAIR-CT’s Farhan Memon, fmemon@cair.com, (203) 517-6526

On October 7, 2023, Zareena Grewal called Israel “a murderous, genocidal settler state” and said Palestinians had “every right to resist through armed struggle.” She also wrote “It’s been such an extraordinary day!” while retweeting a video of the attack, and “Settlers are not civilians.”

While CAIR has a legitimate role in explaining Islam, and teachers’ unions have interests in representing educators, neither has special authority to determine how the history of Jewish heritage and sovereignty should be presented to Connecticut schoolchildren.

Connecticut recognizes the importance of community representation. Its antisemitism working group reserves two seats for the Jewish Federations Association of Connecticut. Yet the Arab and Islamic Studies legislation which is pushing to cover the establishment of the Jewish State provides no comparable guarantee for Jewish historians or pro-Israel educators.

“Nakba” rally on the lawn of West Hartford Town Hall. (photo: John Cappadona)

The “genocide” accusation demonstrates why that representation is essential.

In February 1947, British Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin told Parliament that Arab leaders were “opposed to the creation of a Jewish State in any part of Palestine.” Arab leaders had rejected partition in 1937 and rejected it again when the United Nations proposed Jewish and Arab states in November 1947. Meanwhile, Jewish leaders accepted the UN plan.

When Israel declared independence on May 14, 1948, armies from five neighboring Arab countries invaded the following day. Only three years after the Holocaust, Jews were fighting to defend their restored sovereignty against armies determined to prevent the Jewish state from surviving.

Meanwhile, Jordanian forces captured Jerusalem’s Old City, expelled its Jewish residents, and destroyed or desecrated synagogues. Jordan occupied and subsequently annexed eastern Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria, excluding Jews from the Western Wall and other holy sites. Its 1954 nationality law explicitly excluded Jews from a provision granting citizenship to qualifying former Palestinian nationals.

Across Arab countries and Iran, roughly 1 million Jews left over the following decades, driven by varying combinations of expulsion, persecution, violence, discriminatory laws and emigration. Israel absorbed hundreds of thousands of them. That constituent is the largest demographic in Israel today.

This was the history of the Jewish people in the years surrounding Israel’s founding: Holocaust survivors defending their independence, Jews expelled from Jerusalem, ancient communities disappearing across the Middle East, and a neighboring Arab kingdom writing Jewish exclusion into its citizenship law.

Yet advocates want Connecticut students to learn that the establishment of the Jewish state was genocide against local Palestinian Arabs. The accusation turns a defensive war for Jewish sovereignty into a supposed campaign of extermination. Teaching that accusation as established fact would substitute political propaganda for historical education.

But there is an even more basic question. Why should this particular conflict occupy such a prominent place in a course about two billion Muslims?

Islam originated in Arabia, with Mecca and Medina as its foundational holy cities. Its civilization stretches from Morocco to Indonesia, encompassing great empires, religious traditions, literature, mathematics, medicine, architecture and philosophy. the Stateless Arabs from Palestine (SAPs) represent only a small fraction of the Muslim world.

The Land of Israel, by contrast, is the birthplace and geographic heart of Judaism. Jerusalem was the capital of ancient Jewish kingdoms and home to the Jewish Temple more than a thousand years before Islam emerged. Jews have prayed toward Jerusalem and maintained their connection to the land through centuries of exile because Judaism, unlike Christianity and Islam, is an ancient land-based folk religion.

The founding of Israel belongs in the study of Judaism, not Islam.

The testimony surrounding this new Arab and Islamic coursework reveals the what some advocates want students to learn: that Israel has always been an illegal and genocidal state since its inception. It is no stretch that students will believe that anyone who supports such racist country is a racist.

CAIR has fourteen centuries of Islamic civilization to help explain. Teachers’ unions have educators to represent. Neither should turn a course about Arab and Muslim history into a campaign distorting Jewish sovereignty and vilifying Jews.

A curriculum that teaches children to call Israel’s founding a “genocide” is not teaching history. It is teaching jihadi propaganda.

The Countries the New York Times Doesn’t See

Chico Harlan wrote a beautiful article in The New York Times about Malawi, a poor African country struggling with devastating droughts, unpredictable flooding and the destruction of its agricultural economy. Joao Silva’s extraordinary photographs capture the beauty of the landscape and the hardships of the people who depend on it.

It is excellent journalism. But one passage is revealing.

Harlan quotes Malawi’s chief secretary, Justin Saidi, explaining that the government has been appealing to development banks and countries “like Britain and Australia” for assistance in implementing its El Niño preparedness plan.

Australia?

The United States has historically been Malawi’s largest bilateral donor, providing an average of more than $400 million annually between 2017 and 2023. America also contributed millions in emergency assistance during Malawi’s devastating 2024 El Niño drought. Britain has been another important donor, but Australia is nowhere near the top of the list.

Yet readers hear about Australia while America goes unmentioned in the discussion of international assistance.

Even more curious is the absence of Israel.

Israeli-founded Innovation: Africa led by Sivan Yaari has completed more than 200 solar and water projects in Malawi, reportedly benefiting approximately one million people. The organization uses Israeli technology to bring clean water and electricity to rural villages, installing solar-powered pumps and training local residents to maintain the systems.

IsraAID, another Israeli humanitarian organization, responded to Cyclone Freddy in 2023 by rehabilitating damaged boreholes and restoring clean water to more than 100,000 Malawians. Israeli medical organizations have treated children with serious heart conditions, trained healthcare workers and introduced medical technology. The two countries have also developed an agricultural employment partnership that allows Malawians to work in Israel and send money home.

Then there is the recent bonding of Israel and Malawi since the October 7 massacre by Gazans of Israelis. The two countries are becoming much more integrated.

Water, agriculture, healthcare and economic resilience. These are precisely the challenges Harlan describes so effectively.

Harlan is no stranger to either country. His recent reporting has repeatedly criticized American climate and foreign-aid policies, including the Trump administration’s retreat from international climate commitments. His 2018 reporting from Gaza focused on Palestinian casualties during confrontations with Israeli forces.

He also previously worked as a journalist in Sydney, Australia.

Perhaps Malawi’s chief secretary simply offered Britain and Australia as examples. We do not know what else was discussed during the interview or why those particular countries survived the editing process.

A journalist can report every fact accurately and still leave readers with a distorted understanding of the world. The selection of facts, the people interviewed, the questions asked and the information omitted all shape the story.

Harlan’s article makes Malawi’s suffering impossible to ignore. His photographs and reporting deserve praise. Yet readers come away knowing that Malawi is seeking help from Australia, without learning about America’s enormous financial contributions or the Israeli organizations already bringing water, electricity and medical care to Malawian communities.

The most revealing biases in journalism are sometimes found in the facts that never make it onto the page.

The New York Times Invites a Guest to Explain Antisemitic Language

I want to thank The New York Times for publishing today’s guest essay, “The Spanish Shylock Problem,” about the antisemitism embedded in everyday language. It is a welcome subject for a newspaper that has done so much to negatively shape the language used to describe Jews and Israel.

The author focuses on the Royal Spanish Academy, whose official dictionary includes a definition of judío, the Spanish word for Jew, as a miserly or usurious person. In 2024, an Argentine judge ordered the Academy to remove the definition following a campaign by Jewish organizations. The Academy refused, explaining that dictionaries record how people actually use words.

Which came first, the antisemitic stereotype or the dictionary definition? Did the Academy simply record centuries of prejudice, or has its dictionary helped perpetuate that prejudice by presenting Jewish stinginess as an accepted meaning of the word Jew?

The essay could have challenged the stereotype with some actual evidence. A national American survey found that 76% of Jewish households donated to charity, compared with 63% of non-Jewish households. Median annual donations were $1,200 for Jews, twice those of non-Jews. Among Jewish donors, 92% contributed to non-Jewish organizations. Hardly the portrait of a miserly people.

The essay also discusses Spanish expressions associating Jews with secrecy. Here, a little history would have been useful beyond generic persecution to the specific religious nature of the attacks on Jews.

The Spanish Inquisition forced Jews to convert, flee or risk death. The Inquisition existed in Mexico and Latin America for hundreds of years until the 1820s. Many converts continued practicing Judaism secretly, risking imprisonment, torture or execution. Their descendants spread throughout Latin America, where a 2018 genetic study published in Nature Communications found evidence of widespread ancestry – 23 percent! – associated with converso migration.

The persecutors forced Jews into secrecy. Their descendants inherited a language that characterized Jews as secretive.

Society has shown that it can change its vocabulary. Polite society has largely abandoned the N-word, recognizing it as an ugly racial slur. Muslim organizations have campaigned to separate Islam from terrorism, arguing that the association unfairly casts suspicion on nearly two billion Muslims rather than the radical jihadists responsible for terrorist attacks.

Yet centuries-old stereotypes about Jews remain embedded in dictionaries, journalism and everyday speech. The willingness to reconsider offensive language seems to stop when Jews are the subject.

William Safire spent decades examining the origins and meanings of words in his celebrated New York Times column, “On Language.” He understood how much a single word could convey.

In July 2014, as antisemitic attacks swept across Europe during the Gaza war, three Times articles described the protests as having an antisemitic “tinge.” A slight whiff of Jew-hatred. Dan Bilefsky used the expression on July 21, Helene Cooper and Somini Sengupta on July 24, and Jodi Rudoren on July 27.

And what was going on? On July 20, anti-Israel rioters attacked a synagogue in the Paris suburb of Sarcelles, while Jewish businesses were looted. A week earlier, demonstrators in Paris had threatened synagogues, chanting “Death to the Jews” and “Hitler was right.” French Prime Minister Manuel Valls condemned the violence, explicitly identifying the attacks on Jewish institutions as antisemitism and racism.

A “tinge” of antisemitism.

The newspaper seemed determined to preserve the distinction between criticism of Israel and antisemitism, even when protesters themselves had erased it. Calling the hatred a “tinge” allowed the events to remain principally political demonstrations, with antisemitism appearing as an unfortunate side effect.

“Pro-Palestinian demonstrations are continuing in Paris, Berlin, Vienna, Amsterdam and other European cities, some of them assuming an anti-Semitic tinge.” – New York Times article on July 24, 2014, “As Much of the World Frowns on Israel, Americans Hold Out Support”

The Spanish Academy says it merely records how people speak. The Times cannot hide behind that explanation. Its journalists and editors decide how events are described, which words are emphasized and what readers are encouraged to believe.

I appreciate today’s guest essay. It is refreshing to see the Times devote space to the antisemitism that survives in ordinary language, especially as The Times has spent years choosing the words through which readers understand Jews and Israel.

It might begin its examination of antisemitic language with the words it chooses itself.

A Morocco Plan for Israel

The United Nations may have discovered a new approach to resolving territorial disputes. It is called accepting reality.

For fifty years, Morocco has controlled most of Western Sahara, a former Spanish colony. It has built cities, roads, ports and businesses, and encouraged Moroccans to make their homes there. Their children and grandchildren have grown up knowing no other home.

The indigenous Sahrawi people have long demanded independence. In 1991, the UN established a peacekeeping mission to organize a referendum on their future. The vote never happened.

So Morocco continued developing the territory while the UN continued demanding self-determination. For decades, neither side moved.

Recently, something remarkable happened.

In October 2025, the UN Security Council adopted Resolution 2797, making Morocco’s proposal for Sahrawi autonomy under Moroccan sovereignty the basis for negotiations. The UN was prepared to consider a future that accommodated Moroccan control rather than reversed it.

“a just, lasting, and mutually acceptable solution to the dispute; affirming
that genuine autonomy under Moroccan sovereignty could constitute a most feasible solution; and further welcoming the commitment of Council members to facilitate progress” – UNSC Resolution 2797

A year later, the Security Council failed to renew the referendum mission. After 35 years, the UN was closing a mission that had never held its referendum.

Consider what this means for Israel.

In 1967, Israel took control of Judea and Samaria, including eastern Jerusalem, from Jordan. Jordan had seized the territory in 1948 and annexed it in 1950, an illegal claim that received almost no international recognition. During Jordanian rule, Jewish communities were ethnically cleansed, including from the Old City of Jerusalem and Gush Etzion.

Jews had lived in these places long before 1948. Hebron, Bethlehem, Shiloh and Beit El are central to Jewish history and religion. The Jewish connection to these places predates Morocco, Spain and the United Nations. In modern times, the lands were central to the international Palestine Mandate establishing a Jewish homeland.

Today, more than half a million Jews live in Judea and Samaria. They have built communities, schools, synagogues and businesses. Their children and grandchildren have grown up knowing no other home.

Israel has not formally annexed Judea and Samaria, although some Israeli leaders advocate doing so. Yet the UN continues to demand an end to Jewish construction, including natural growth, and declares Jewish communities established since 1967 to have no legal validity.

The UN is now prepared to negotiate a solution in which Sahrawis could govern their own affairs without requiring Moroccan families to abandon their homes. Why should the same possibility be excluded for Palestinian Arabs and Jews?

A Morocco Plan for Israel would begin with the people who actually live there. Palestinian Arabs would govern their own affairs, with meaningful political and civil rights. Jewish communities would remain. Sovereignty and security would be negotiated without making the removal of Jewish families a prerequisite.

For decades, the UN has condemned Israel for changing the demographic realities of Judea and Samaria. In Western Sahara, it has now made those same realities the starting point for negotiations.

Perhaps the UN has learned something from Morocco. It is time to apply that lesson to Israel.

A Fresh Start on Immigration

The November elections offer an opportunity to reconsider how governments should treat people who have lived for decades in communities where their legal right to remain is challenged.

Hundreds of thousands have built their lives in these communities. They work, pay taxes, own homes, establish businesses and raise families. They have become part of the social and economic fabric of the places they call home.

Many were born there. Their parents and grandparents established roots decades ago. They attend local schools, speak the language and know no other home. Why should children bear the consequences of decisions made before they were born?

Critics argue that their presence violates the law and that granting legal recognition would reward unlawful behavior. But laws can change, and governments must weigh legal obligations against the human consequences of uprooting established communities.

Mass removal would separate families from their homes, destroy businesses and empty neighborhoods. Decades of peaceful residence create human interests that cannot simply be dismissed.

These are familiar arguments in the American debate over immigration enforcement and the treatment of undocumented immigrants.

Those same humanitarian considerations arise in another debate involving more than half a million Jews living in Judea and Samaria.

An ancient doorway in Herodium in Judea, sealed with rocks until it can be secured (photo: First One Through)

Those advocating changes to ICE’s enforcement policies emphasize family unity and the human costs of removal. Those principles can also inform discussions about Jewish communities in Judea and Samaria.

Imagine French Leftists Opposing a Tibetan Real Estate Fair

Imagine Tibetan Buddhist monks helping organize a private real estate fair in Paris for Tibetan families interested in buying homes in their ancestral homeland.

As a matter of politics, China governs Tibet and considers it an integral part of its territory and rejects Tibetan independence. As a matter of religion, history and heritage, Tibetans have maintained their connections to their homeland for centuries.

The real estate event is a test between these viewpoints.

The fair brings together developers, real estate agents, lawyers and families considering where to live, raise children and rebuild their communities. But against this personal desire, imagine French left-wing politicians and activists calling for the fair to be prohibited, accusing organizers of facilitating international crimes and questioning whether French citizens relocating there should continue receiving consular services.

There would undoubtedly be questions about why a private gathering of families and property professionals had become the subject of such political scrutiny.

Now replace the Tibetan families with Jewish families, and Tibet with Israel.

On November 15, the privately organized Icube Israeli real estate fair is scheduled to hold its 95th edition in Paris. Established in 1990, the fair brings together developers, brokers, lawyers, financial advisers and families interested in purchasing homes in Israel. It has enflamed anti-Israel agitators and politicians.

Aymeric Caron called for authorities to prohibit an October aliyah fair, alleging that it promoted immigration to what he described as illegal Israeli settlements.

Ersilia Soudais reportedly sought cancellation of similar events in Paris, Marseille and Lyon.

Andrée Taurinya accused French authorities of “complicit silence” for allowing aliyah fairs and raised allegations of complicity in war crimes. She also proposed restrictions on consular services for French citizens living in Jewish communities in Judea and Samaria.

Sylvie Ferrer, in a November 3 parliamentary question, specifically raised concerns about the upcoming November 15 Icube event, citing its previous exhibitors and alleged connections to settlement-related projects.

The controversy has also reached the media. TRT Français has published critical coverage of Israeli real estate fairs in Paris, highlighting allegations about properties in disputed territories and reporting calls for demonstrations against the events.

All this is unfolding in France, where antisemitic incidents have increased sharply and many Jewish families are reconsidering their future.

If there would be no outcry of Tibetan monks holding a real estate fair to buy property in Tibet, there should be no cause célèbre for Jews buying property in the Jewish holy land.