French families struggle to afford groceries. Violent riots have shaken major cities. Government debt is soaring, public services are strained, and officials insist there is no money for higher wages.
Yet France just committed another $5.5 million to build infrastructure for Palestinian Arabs in Judea and Samaria.
On November 17, as 146,000 demonstrators protested wages and deteriorating services, France pledged €5 million for Palestinian roads, electricity, water and other infrastructure in disputed territory. Just days earlier, Cenk Uygur blamed France’s riots on unaffordability, Israel and Zionists. He has said nothing about France sending money to Palestinian Arabs.
Of course, $5.5 million won’t rescue France’s finances. Neither would eliminating American aid to Israel make groceries affordable. But that never troubled Uygur’s argument.
The problem was never foreign aid. It was aid to Jews.
Stupidity from the mouth of an antisemite. If my grandmother had wheels she’d be a wagon.
Antisemitism is driving French Jews to consider leaving. France’s political and economic future may determine how many actually go.
France has roughly 436,000 Jews. Nearly two-thirds have considered leaving.
That is the startling finding of a new American Jewish Committee study released in November 2026. Among 500 Jewish adults surveyed by IFOP, 64% reported having considered leaving France, up from 52% in 2024. Eighty-two percent reported experiencing antisemitism during their lifetimes. Nearly half have stopped wearing visible Jewish symbols, while 29% have removed the mezuzahs from their doors.
If Jean-Luc Mélenchon becomes president in 2027, 69% say they would consider leaving, including 40% who would certainly consider it. A Marine Le Pen presidency would prompt 31% to consider departure.
For centuries, France has been home to one of the world’s great Jewish communities. Today, many of its Jews are questioning whether their children should remain.
How many will leave by 2040? And will antisemitism alone determine the answer?
The Jews Who Have Already Left
French Jews have been leaving for decades, with Israel receiving the largest documented share.
Departures accelerated after the murder of Jewish schoolchildren in Toulouse in 2012 and the attacks culminating in the Hyper Cacher supermarket massacre in Paris in 2015.
Between 2014 and 2016, approximately 18,800 French Jews moved to Israel. The movement has accelerated again. By October 2026, Israeli authorities reported approximately 3,950 arrivals from France, already exceeding the roughly 3,400 recorded in all of 2025.
France is losing families raising the next generation and adults who might otherwise have spent their working lives in France.
Yet many who want to leave cannot. A doctor may need new qualifications to practice abroad. A business owner may be unable to sell a business. A family may depend on elderly parents. Some Jews who moved to Israel have returned because they could not rebuild their careers or afford the life they left behind.
Fear may start the conversation. Jobs, housing, family and finances often determine the decision.
What South Africa and Argentina Teach Us
South Africa once had a Jewish community exceeding 100,000. Today it numbers approximately 49,000.
Its Jews did not leave principally because of antisemitism. Political uncertainty, violence, crime and declining confidence in the country’s future persuaded many families that their children would have better opportunities elsewhere.
Argentina followed another path. Its Jewish community endured military dictatorship, hyperinflation and repeated economic crises. The financial collapse of 2001–2002 produced another wave of Jewish emigration.
Argentina’s Jews did not suddenly discover antisemitism in 2001. Their country was collapsing economically, and many who could leave did so.
France has already demonstrated how antisemitic violence can accelerate Jewish emigration. South Africa shows how political insecurity can sustain departures. Argentina shows how economic collapse can accelerate them.
France is neither South Africa nor Argentina. But their histories expose a danger that an exclusive focus on antisemitism misses.
The French Problem
The AJC survey offers a clue that its headlines have largely overlooked.
Twenty-six percent of French Jewish respondents cite concern about the future of Jews in France as their principal reason for considering departure. Another 22% cite concern about France’s future generally, while 8% cite economic reasons. Taken together, 30% of respondents identify France’s broader future or economic prospects as their principal concern, compared with 26% who specifically identify the future of Jews.
The survey also finds that 74% of French people are pessimistic about their country’s future, compared with 61% of French Jews. French Jews are not alone in questioning France’s direction. They are confronting those larger doubts while also facing antisemitism.
And France has reasons to worry.
The European Commission’s November 2026 forecast projects economic growth of just 0.4% this year and 0.6% in 2027. Unemployment is expected to climb from 8.4% in 2026 to 9.8% in 2028.
Government debt, already 115.7% of GDP in 2025, is projected to reach 123.2% by 2028. The budget deficit is forecast to remain above 5% of GDP through 2028. France is borrowing heavily while its economy barely grows. Its political divisions make serious fiscal reform increasingly difficult. Eventually, somebody must pay.
Higher taxes, reduced services and weaker economic opportunities could follow. For French Jews already questioning their future, these pressures would compound the antisemitism they face.
Antisemitism makes Jews question their safety. Political instability makes them question their rights. Economic deterioration makes them question their children’s future. Together, these pressures can turn the desire to leave into the decision to go.
Demographer Sergio DellaPergola has identified relative employment conditions as an important influence on aliyah. Economic opportunity can encourage migration alongside the desire to escape insecurity, provided opportunities abroad are attractive enough to make relocation practical.
How Many Will Leave?
Starting with France’s 436,000 Jews, I examined how emigration might unfold under three conditions: continued economic weakness, prolonged deterioration and a severe national crisis.
France need not experience an Argentine-style collapse to lose a substantial portion of its Jewish community.
France, 2026–2040
Low
Middle
High
Antisemitism
Persistent
Worsening
Worsening
Economy
Weak but stable
Prolonged deterioration
Severe crisis
Politics
Institutions hold
Repeated instability
Major loss of confidence
Illustrative gross departures
~56,000
~82,000
~128,000
Equivalent share of today’s Jewish population
13%
19%
29%
The low case assumes that elevated migration gradually subsides toward 0.9% annually. The middle case includes several years approaching 1.8%. The high case requires a much more serious crisis, with rates approaching 3.8% for a limited period.
These are illustrative scenarios based on historical migration experience, not statistical forecasts or predictions of a French economic collapse. They represent gross departures, not permanent population losses. Some emigrants will return, while births, deaths and immigration into France will also affect the population.
Under the middle case, cumulative departures would equal roughly one-fifth of today’s French Jewish population. Under the high case, nearly three in ten.
When Jewish families leave France, the loss extends beyond those boarding the plane. Their children may grow up elsewhere, establish families elsewhere and build the Jewish communities of other countries rather than France.
The future of French Jewry will be shaped not only by those who leave, but by the generations who will never be born or raised in France because their parents chose to build their lives elsewhere.
France’s Choice
The AJC report calls on France to confront antisemitism and restore the confidence of its Jewish citizens. But protecting Jews from antisemitism may not be enough to keep them in France.
France could strengthen security around synagogues, prosecute antisemites and protect Jewish rights, yet still lose tens of thousands of Jews to countries whose futures they trust more.
The AJC report asks France to protect its Jews. This analysis suggests that France must also protect itself.
The analysis begins with approximately 436,000 Jews in France and applies three illustrative annual emigration-rate paths from 2026 through 2040.
Year
Low
Middle
High
2026
1.2%
1.2%
1.2%
2027
0.9%
1.2%
1.5%
2028
0.9%
1.3%
2.0%
2029
0.9%
1.5%
2.7%
2030
0.9%
1.7%
3.5%
2031
0.9%
1.8%
3.8%
2032
0.9%
1.8%
3.6%
2033
0.9%
1.6%
3.0%
2034
0.9%
1.5%
2.6%
2035
0.9%
1.4%
2.3%
2036
0.9%
1.3%
2.0%
2037
0.9%
1.2%
1.8%
2038
0.9%
1.1%
1.6%
2039
0.9%
1.1%
1.4%
2040
0.9%
1.0%
1.2%
The rates are illustrative assumptions informed by historical migration experience, not statistically fitted estimates. No probabilities are assigned to the scenarios. The model excludes births, deaths, return migration and immigration into France and therefore does not predict the Jewish population remaining in 2040.
“Too big to fail” entered our vocabulary when governments rescued banks whose collapse threatened the global economy. General Motors and Chrysler were bailed out because too many jobs and communities depended on them. Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s CEO, may be too critical to permanently dismiss, given his central role in the AI revolution.
Size and importance confer protection. When the cost of losing something exceeds the cost of saving it, society finds a way to protect it.
But what happens when the calculation runs in reverse?
There are fewer than 16 million Jews worldwide, less than 0.2% of humanity. Even before the Holocaust, there were only about 16.5 million. Israel, the world’s only Jewish state, is smaller than New Jersey.
Jews may simply be too small to matter.
Consider the calculation facing a politician, university president, corporate executive, or international institution. Defending Jews may win the appreciation of a tiny minority. Remaining silent may cost nothing. Attacking Israel may even bring political rewards.
And consider the other side of the calculation.
There are roughly two billion Muslims worldwide, alongside insanely wealthy governments, powerful international organizations, and activist movements hostile to Israel. Even a small fraction of this much larger population can exert substantial political and financial pressure. Qatar alone has invested enormous resources in universities, media, sports, and international influence.
For politicians and institutions calculating rewards and consequences, defending Jews can become a liability. Abandoning them can be the easier choice.
Boycott of Philly “Zionist” businessesMayor demanding no intimidation or violence but not condemning the event
And Jews face a peculiar contradiction. Despite their tiny numbers, antisemitic conspiracy theories portray them as controlling governments, banks, media, and world events. Israel, a small country, is depicted as an outsized threat to international peace.
Jews are simultaneously too small to command protection and supposedly too powerful to deserve it. Their actual vulnerability makes them easy to abandon. Their imagined power makes them easy to attack.
An ancient people who survived empires, exile, persecution, and the Holocaust are still being judged by whether defending them is worth the political cost. On a purely selfish basis, abandoning Jews may be the rational choice.
A society that protects only those powerful enough to demand protection is not defending rights. It is accommodating power.
Jews seek no special protection. They are entitled to equal protection, even when providing it is politically costly. This is where the treatment of Jews becomes a test of something much larger than antisemitism.
Majority rule is democracy’s mechanism, and minority rights are among the essential safeguards of a liberal democratic republic. Without those safeguards, elections can become little more than a means for the powerful to impose their will on the powerless.
Jews lack the numbers to guarantee their own protection through the ballot box. Their security depends on a society’s willingness to uphold principles that transcend political advantage. And if those principles can be discarded when Jews become inconvenient, they can be discarded for any minority.
George Washington’s letter to the synagogue in Newport, RI in 1790
The banks were too big to fail. The automobile companies were too important to lose. Jews may be too small to matter in the calculations of political power. Yet their treatment represents a moral threshold for every society claiming to embrace liberal values.
The truest test of a democratic republic is not how it serves the majority, but whether it protects the rights of those too few to protect themselves.
In 1999, Muslim-majority countries launched a campaign at the United Nations to protect Islam from criticism. Led by Pakistan on behalf of the Organization of Islamic Conference, now the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), they sought international condemnation of the defamation of religion, particularly Islam.
Governments already prohibited religious discrimination and violence. The OIC wanted to go further, establishing protections for religious beliefs themselves against disparagement.
In 2005, a Danish newspaper published twelve cartoons of Muhammad, including one depicting the Islamic prophet with a bomb in his turban. Protests erupted across the Muslim world. Embassies were attacked, hundred of people were killed, and cartoonists received death threats.
The cartoons had not denied Muslims jobs, housing or religious freedom. They had insulted Islam. That was precisely the offense the OIC wanted governments to address.
The campaign had intensified after September 11, 2001, as Muslim governments sought to prevent Islam from being associated with terrorism. In 2007, the UN Human Rights Council included respect for religions among the considerations for restricting freedom of expression.
But the effort eventually met resistance. In 2011, the Human Rights Council shifted its emphasis away from defamation of religions toward protecting individuals from religious discrimination and violence. The UN Human Rights Committee subsequently reaffirmed that blasphemy prohibitions were generally incompatible with freedom of expression.
People have rights. Religions do not have a right to be free from criticism.
Yet the world contorted to the sensitivities of two billion Muslims. Consider that it has become standard policy of many institutions in the west – such as universities and mainstream media – to not show pictures of the Islamic prophet to protect the sensitivities of some religious Muslims.
In an ten-year anniversary story ABOUT THE DANISH CARTOONS, PBS made a disclaimer at beginning of the story that it was not going to show the cartoons: “In an editor’s note: we will not air the cartoons. It is our policy to not show images of the prophet Mohammed because doing so is offensive to some viewers.”
Twenty-seven years after the OIC launched its campaign, New Jersey is considering legislation that threatens to blur that boundary about speech against an ideology and discrimination against people.
Assemblyman Joe Danielsen introduced Assembly Bill A1146 for the 2026 legislative session, establishing a definition of Islamophobia for use in discrimination investigations.
Much of the legislation addresses genuine prejudice against Muslims, including conspiracy theories about Muslim control of government, accusations of divided loyalty, and assertions that Muslims have a unique propensity for terrorism. But the definition also includes: “hostility and fear of Islam, and as a result, a fear of and aversion to all Muslims or the majority of Muslims.”
Islam is a religion. Muslims are people. They are not interchangeable.
A Jew can fear Islamic teachings that call for the murder of Jews without hating all Muslims. A Hindu can condemn Islamic persecution of Hindus. A former Muslim can denounce apostasy laws. A woman can oppose Islamic restrictions on women. A cartoonist can draw Muhammad. None should have to demonstrate affection for Islam to establish that they harbor no prejudice against Muslims.
New Jersey directs public officials and law enforcement officers to consider its definition when investigating alleged discrimination. A university professor who criticizes Islamic law and subsequently faces a discrimination complaint from a Muslim student could find his statements examined as evidence of prejudice.
The bill does not completely outlaw criticism of Islam. It expressly preserves First Amendment protections, and its definition requires fear of Islam to result in aversion toward Muslims. But it invites government investigators to consider criticism of a religion when determining whether someone is prejudiced against its followers.
What the OIC could not secure at the United Nations may now find its way into American law.
One of the gunmen who killed people in Paris in 2015 during the Charlie Hebdo attacks became radicalized from the 2005 Danish cartoons incident and tried to join al Qaeda
The legislation contains another revealing contradiction.
New Jersey’s definition borrows heavily from the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism. Both address conspiracy theories, divided loyalty and prejudice against religious minorities. The IHRA definition explicitly protects criticism of Israel comparable to criticism of any other country, and New Jersey’s bill similarly protects criticism of Muslim-majority countries.
Yet it offers no comparable protection for criticism of religion itself. This omission is especially striking given the position of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR). CAIR-New Jersey supported earlier versions of the Islamophobia legislation while opposing New Jersey’s proposed adoption of the IHRA definition of antisemitism.
Sunni Action Committee protestors in Pakistan, February 2008 (photo: Athar Hussein, Reuters)
The legislation’s sponsors have described their proposal as the nation’s first state definition of Islamophobia. If adopted, it could become a model for other states. That would be problematic.
New Jersey can protect Muslims without protecting Islam from criticism. Strike the reference to hostility and fear of Islam. Define Islamophobia as prejudice against Muslims. Explicitly protect criticism of Islamic teachings, religious figures and practices, just as the legislation protects criticism of Muslim-majority countries.
Christians cannot demand that government protect Jesus from ridicule. Jews cannot demand that government prohibit criticism of the Torah. Muslims cannot demand that government shield Muhammad or the Quran from scrutiny.
The OIC sought international recognition that insulting Islam was an offense requiring government intervention. New Jersey proposes something different, but potentially just as troubling: allowing criticism of Islam to become evidence of prejudice against Muslims.
Muslims deserve protection from discrimination just like every one else. Islam does not deserve protection from criticism just like every other faith.
I always look forward to Tikvah’s annual Jewish Leadership Conference. This year, some 1,100 people packed a New York City venue to hear Ruth Wisse, Dara Horn, Micah Goodman and an extraordinary collection of Jewish thinkers and political leaders.
Dara Horn addressing the audience at Tikvah’s Jewish Leadership Conference on November 15, 2026 (photo: First One Through)
Several speakers noted that the conference invitation had listed the location as “TBD,” as Jewish gatherings increasingly conceal their venues until shortly before the event for security reasons. What once would have seemed extraordinary has become routine.
Yet the atmosphere was uplifting. There was warmth in seeing familiar faces and being surrounded by people who shared a deep concern for the Jewish people and the direction of American society.
The conference itself has evolved since it was founded in 2017. In earlier years, Tikvah offered breakout sessions, allowing attendees to choose among competing speakers and subjects. The unified program eliminates the logistical challenges and frustration of missing other sessions. But it also reflects something deeper.
People come for the intellectual content, but increasingly for chizuk, the strength that comes from being among fellow travelers. They want to bond with people who understand their concerns and share their distress at what is happening around them. The gathering has become as much about strengthening a community as expanding its knowledge.
The format also gives Tikvah a larger platform to showcase its growing ambitions. For years, the organization has emphasized the Judeo-Christian foundations of American civilization. This year’s preceding weekend programming, and the presence of numerous Christian pastors, demonstrated how central that mission has become.
Tikvah recognizes that Jews alone cannot preserve America’s Judeo-Christian inheritance. Its growing partnership with the vastly larger Christian community reflects an ambition extending well beyond Jewish education to the renewal of American civilization.
The organization announced expanding initiatives to train teachers and leaders of Jewish day schools, develop educational materials and bring stronger curricula into America’s struggling public schools. These are substantial and worthwhile undertakings, aimed at raising young adults with the knowledge, confidence and moral grounding to withstand the pressures of contemporary society.
Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) comments were particularly striking. Since the Obama administration, Cruz has warned about growing hostility toward Israel and Jews on the political left. Now he spoke with dismay about the antisemitism within his own Republican Party, calling out several right-wing bigots whom he said must be expelled and expunged completely and permanently.
The conference did not avoid the uncomfortable realities of contemporary America. Yet as the day progressed, I became increasingly uneasy about the prescriptions.
Education. Facts. History. Better storytelling.
Rabbi Meir Soloveichik concluded the day with an appeal for the power of stories. It was a fitting message for a gathering devoted to Jewish civilization. For thousands of years, Jews have preserved their identity through books, teachers, arguments and stories. Tikvah excels at all of them.
But where was the discussion about engagement for those less hungry for the richness of culture, history and honest debate?
In 2022, I bemoaned that We Listen to Idiots. I explored the growing disconnect between intellectual authority and popular influence. We fight with facts, they fight with feelings. We build logic, they build engagement. We look for truth, they look for traction.
Tikvah had assembled some of the finest Jewish minds in America. But millions of Americans under 35 are getting their understanding of Jews, Israel, America, politics and history from influencers whose principal qualification is their ability to attract attention.
The People of the Book are trying to win an argument in a world that increasingly refuses to read.
Rabbi Meir Soloveichik addressing the audience at Tikvah’s Jewish Leadership Conference on November 15, 2026 (photo: First One Through)
For decades, parents have worried about what their children eat. We understand the dangers of excessive sugar, trans fats and processed junk food. Yet we allow young people to spend hours every day consuming intellectual junk food.
Algorithms reward outrage. Influencers compete through provocation. Foreign propagandists and bot networks exploit platforms whose business models reward attention, regardless of whether the content is truthful or poisonous.
Young people are fed a continuous diet of anger, resentment and ideological certainty. Their attention spans, patience and willingness to consider competing arguments are being shaped by the same machinery.
And our response is to improve the curriculum. Tikvah is improving the quality of the meal while the younger generation is consuming poison throughout the day.
There is an urgent battle to be fought at local school boards over curricula and educational priorities, and nationally over foreign funding and influence in American education. The social media platforms themselves must also be confronted. Foreign manipulation and coordinated bot networks need to be exposed and disrupted, while the algorithms that amplify hatred and conspiracy deserve the same serious scrutiny we apply to harmful ingredients in our children’s food.
But protecting young people from intellectual junk food is only part of the challenge. We must also compete for their attention.
Yes, we need Ruth Wisse and Andrew Roberts. We need Micah Goodman, master educators, rabbis and pastors. But we also need the cultural reach of a Sydney Sweeney.
The people shaping the next generation are not necessarily the people with the greatest knowledge. They are the people who command its attention.
Tikvah’s educational programs will take years to mature. Will they reach enough young people? Will its Christian alliances achieve sufficient scale? Will either move quickly enough to counter the cultural forces already shaping an entire generation?
By the end of the conference, I was grateful for the extraordinary minds Tikvah had assembled, the community it had strengthened and the ambitious programs it was building. Those gathered had enjoyed an intellectual feast and received the chizuk they desperately needed.
But outside that room, millions of young Americans were consuming another meal entirely. And I fear that Tikvah’s intellectual feast cannot nourish a generation raised on a steady diet of poison.
I listened to two podcasts this week. Dan Senor and Mark Halperin discussed the socialist challenge to the Democratic Party. Yossi Klein Halevi and Donniel Hartman discussed Naza, a film accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza that reportedly received a standing ovation lasting nearly 25 minutes.
What struck me was how four intelligent, experienced men struggled to understand movements that no longer accepted their rules of engagement.
Halperin was puzzled that Abdul El-Sayed had not moderated his positions after the midterm elections. How could he expect to accomplish anything without building relationships and cooperating with his colleagues in Washington?
But El-Sayed and the socialist movement have a different ambition. They want to replace the Democratic establishment, not become more effective members of it. Their success is measured by how far they move the party toward their positions, rather than how many colleagues they persuade to join them on individual bills.
Halperin is waiting for El-Sayed to grow into the Democratic Party. El-Sayed wants the Democratic Party to grow into his movement.
The conversation between Halevi and Hartman revealed a similar disconnect. Both men were disturbed by the extraordinary reception for Naza. They questioned its allegations, its presentation of Hamas and the evidence used to condemn Israel’s conduct in Gaza. They approached the film as serious intellectuals, seeking to separate fact from fiction.
But why would an audience applaud for nearly 25 minutes? For anything?
Such enthusiasm is difficult to explain as a careful assessment of military evidence. The film offered something more emotionally satisfying: confirmation of a worldview in which Israel is not simply guilty of particular actions but is fundamentally illegitimate.
The most radical anti-Zionist activists have moved beyond questions of Israeli military conduct. Their accusation of genocide is not confined to the Gaza war. They portray Zionism itself as a colonial and racist enterprise, Israel’s establishment as an original act of ethnic cleansing and the subsequent history of the Jewish state as a continuing campaign against Palestinian Arabs.
Under this worldview, October 7 did not begin a war that Israel was forced to fight. It merely provided another occasion for Israel to reveal its supposedly genocidal character.
As such, no military investigation can answer an accusation that begins with the existence of the Jewish state. No ceasefire can satisfy a movement that regards Zionism itself as the crime.
This presents a particular challenge for the Shalom Hartman Institute.
Hartman has devoted decades to Jewish scholarship, education and the tradition of machloket l’shem shamayim, disagreement for the sake of heaven. Its podcast, For Heaven’s Sake, reflects the belief that serious people can examine competing arguments and emerge with greater understanding.
But that tradition presumes participants recognize one another’s legitimacy. What happens when one side considers the very existence of the Jewish state an offense that no amount of evidence can justify?
Halperin and Senor expect the socialists to learn how to operate within the Democratic Party. Halevi and Hartman expect Israel’s accusers to be persuaded by facts and reason.
They have not recognized that the game itself has changed.
Yet some advocates want the curriculum to teach children that the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 was genocide against Palestinian Arabs, part of the so-called “Nakba.” In doing so, a course about Islamic civilization risks becoming a political campaign against the Jewish state.
In March 2026, Audra King, a professor at Central Connecticut State University and member of the CSU-AAUP faculty union, urged lawmakers to include the “Nakba” in genocide education. She also called for educator unions, along with Muslim, Palestinian and Arab representatives, to participate in developing the curriculum.
Erna Alic, a Trinity College program manager whose family fled Bosnia, similarly urged Connecticut to teach the “Nakba” alongside the Bosnian genocide. That was an actual genocide, not a political smear.
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) also advocated including the “Nakba” in Arab and Islamic Studies, as did anti-Israel groups like Jewish Voice for Peace, although it did not explicitly characterize the events of 1948 as genocide.
The testimony was submitted in support of HB 5328, which did not itself become law. Connecticut nevertheless enacted a separate provision directing the development of Arab and Islamic Studies resources.
The controversy then moved from what should be taught to who would write the lessons.
A September investigation by Connecticut Centinal, citing State Department of Education records, reported that the curriculum design team included a national CAIR consultant and four educators recommended by CAIR-Connecticut.
Proposed CT teachers for “Nakba” submitted via email from CAIR-CT’s Farhan Memon, fmemon@cair.com, (203) 517-6526
On October 7, 2023, Zareena Grewal called Israel “a murderous, genocidal settler state” and said Palestinians had “every right to resist through armed struggle.” She also wrote “It’s been such an extraordinary day!” while retweeting a video of the attack, and “Settlers are not civilians.”
While CAIR has a legitimate role in explaining Islam, and teachers’ unions have interests in representing educators, neither has special authority to determine how the history of Jewish heritage and sovereignty should be presented to Connecticut schoolchildren.
Connecticut recognizes the importance of community representation. Its antisemitism working group reserves two seats for the Jewish Federations Association of Connecticut. Yet the Arab and Islamic Studies legislation which is pushing to cover the establishment of the Jewish State provides no comparable guarantee for Jewish historians or pro-Israel educators.
“Nakba” rally on the lawn of West Hartford Town Hall. (photo: John Cappadona)
The “genocide” accusation demonstrates why that representation is essential.
In February 1947, British Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin told Parliament that Arab leaders were “opposed to the creation of a Jewish State in any part of Palestine.” Arab leaders had rejected partition in 1937 and rejected it again when the United Nations proposed Jewish and Arab states in November 1947. Meanwhile, Jewish leaders accepted the UN plan.
When Israel declared independence on May 14, 1948, armies from five neighboring Arab countries invaded the following day. Only three years after the Holocaust, Jews were fighting to defend their restored sovereignty against armies determined to prevent the Jewish state from surviving.
Meanwhile, Jordanian forces captured Jerusalem’s Old City, expelled its Jewish residents, and destroyed or desecrated synagogues. Jordan occupied and subsequently annexed eastern Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria, excluding Jews from the Western Wall and other holy sites. Its 1954 nationality law explicitly excluded Jews from a provision granting citizenship to qualifying former Palestinian nationals.
Across Arab countries and Iran, roughly 1 million Jews left over the following decades, driven by varying combinations of expulsion, persecution, violence, discriminatory laws and emigration. Israel absorbed hundreds of thousands of them. That constituent is the largest demographic in Israel today.
This was the history of the Jewish people in the years surrounding Israel’s founding: Holocaust survivors defending their independence, Jews expelled from Jerusalem, ancient communities disappearing across the Middle East, and a neighboring Arab kingdom writing Jewish exclusion into its citizenship law.
Yet advocates want Connecticut students to learn that the establishment of the Jewish state was genocide against local Palestinian Arabs. The accusation turns a defensive war for Jewish sovereignty into a supposed campaign of extermination. Teaching that accusation as established fact would substitute political propaganda for historical education.
But there is an even more basic question. Why should this particular conflict occupy such a prominent place in a course about two billion Muslims?
Islam originated in Arabia, with Mecca and Medina as its foundational holy cities. Its civilization stretches from Morocco to Indonesia, encompassing great empires, religious traditions, literature, mathematics, medicine, architecture and philosophy. the Stateless Arabs from Palestine (SAPs) represent only a small fraction of the Muslim world.
The Land of Israel, by contrast, is the birthplace and geographic heart of Judaism. Jerusalem was the capital of ancient Jewish kingdoms and home to the Jewish Temple more than a thousand years before Islam emerged. Jews have prayed toward Jerusalem and maintained their connection to the land through centuries of exile because Judaism, unlike Christianity and Islam, is an ancient land-based folk religion.
The founding of Israel belongs in the study of Judaism, not Islam.
The testimony surrounding this new Arab and Islamic coursework reveals the what some advocates want students to learn: that Israel has always been an illegal and genocidal state since its inception. It is no stretch that students will believe that anyone who supports such racist country is a racist.
CAIR has fourteen centuries of Islamic civilization to help explain. Teachers’ unions have educators to represent. Neither should turn a course about Arab and Muslim history into a campaign distorting Jewish sovereignty and vilifying Jews.
A curriculum that teaches children to call Israel’s founding a “genocide” is not teaching history. It is teaching jihadi propaganda.
“The internal enemy is usually more deadly and destructive than the external enemy.” – Sami Shawkat (1898-1984) Iraqi politician
That was the warning of Sami Shawkat, one of Iraq’s most influential education officials in the 1930s. He believed a nation needed to identify its enemies within and uproot them before it could prosper.
Shawkat served as director-general of education and later minister of education. He helped organize al-Futuwwa, a militarized nationalist youth movement influenced by European fascism and the Hitler Youth. His speeches circulated in government schools, promoting sacrifice, obedience and militant Arab nationalism.
Jews had lived in Mesopotamia for more than 2,500 years. Yet Iraq’s increasingly radical nationalist movement helped portray them as outsiders and enemies.
Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, supported Iraq’s pro-Axis government in 1941. He subsequently collaborated with Nazi Germany and broadcast antisemitic propaganda to Arab audiences. In June 1941, Baghdad erupted in the Farhud. Approximately 180 Jews were murdered, hundreds were injured, and Jewish homes and businesses were looted.
The Farhud massacre was conducted by Iraqi mobs who had been taught that Jews were internal enemies
Schools had helped spread a militant nationalist ideology in a society where longtime Jewish neighbors were increasingly treated as enemies.
Eighty-five years later, the language of identifying Jewish enemies is being heard in America.
Know Your Enemies
In November 2021, Zahra Billoo, executive director of the San Francisco Bay Area chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), addressed an American Muslims for Palestine conference.
“Know your enemies,” she told the audience.
She named the Anti-Defamation League, Jewish Federations, Hillel chapters and Zionist synagogues. Billoo warned against “polite Zionists,” including those seeking dialogue and cooperation. These were American Jewish institutions. Synagogues, campus organizations, community federations and civil rights advocates were being identified as enemies because of their association with the Jewish State.
Billoo won the 2017 Human Rights Award from the Society of American Law Teachers and the 2018 Community Builder Award from People Acting in Community Together (PACT)
CAIR has also sought to influence how American children learn about Israel, Zionism and antisemitism.
Entering American Schools
In October 2026, George Washington University’s Program on Extremism published The Long Game: CAIR’s Campaign to Influence K–12 Education, by researchers Asher Stern and David Collins. The researchers documented CAIR’s efforts to influence public schools through educator guides, curriculum proposals, teacher resources, district outreach and state education agencies.
In August 2026, CAIR expanded its Unhostile Campus Campaign to include elementary and secondary schools. Its educational resources addressed Palestine, Gaza, October 7, antisemitism and definitions of terrorism.
In Washington State, CAIR participated in months of exchanges with education officials before revised state guidance concerning antisemitism, Islamophobia and political expression was published. The report documented an organized effort to influence the people responsible for determining how politically sensitive subjects are taught.
Other organizations have sought influence through money.
Qatar’s Billions and American Classrooms
Qatar has become a major financial supporter of American educational institutions, with approximately $9 billion in cumulative gifts and contracts reported by U.S. universities, much of it supporting their campuses in Doha.
An October 2026 investigation by the Foundation for Defense of Democracies uncovered another channel: $10.6 million in Qatar Foundation International grants and allocations involving 24 American school districts across 19 states, along with charter schools and universities supporting K–12 programs. The figure represented only a partial accounting of Qatar’s K–12 educational funding. The money supported Arabic-language instruction, teachers, classroom materials and professional development.
In Houston, agreements permitted Qatar Foundation International representatives to observe classrooms. Correspondence showed representatives reviewing lesson plans and providing instructional feedback.
In Austin, Texas, investigators obtained materials from a Qatar-funded Arabic program that included a Saudi government textbook claiming that Western ignorance of Arabs allowed “Zionists to manipulate them.” The familiar antisemitic conspiracy theory of Zionists manipulating Western society had appeared in resources held by an American public school program.
Investigators also identified maps labeling Israel as Palestine.
At PS 261 in Brooklyn, a classroom displayed such a map. The school had received more than $600,000 from Qatar Foundation International between 2015 and 2024, primarily supporting teachers’ salaries. The map was subsequently removed.
Foreign money had reached American classrooms, and investigators were finding troubling materials within programs associated with that funding
Extremism in Religious Education
The investigation also uncovered more than $17 million in Islamic Development Bank funding to at least 50 private Islamic schools in America. One recipient was Brighter Horizons Academy in Texas, which received $995,000 for construction, technology and teacher training.
A separate investigation by Sam Westrop of the Middle East Forum examined textbooks developed by the school’s parent organization, the Islamic Services Foundation.
One presented a Quranic description of certain nonbelievers among the People of the Book and pagans as “the worst of creatures,” under the heading “Words of Wisdom.” Another attributed Muslim weakness to abandoning jihad and submitting to enemies. A third praised Jamal Badawi, who has described Hamas terrorists and suicide bombers as freedom fighters and martyrs. It also praised CAIR and its national leader, Nihad Awad.
CAIR’s Nihad Awad with Reps. Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) and Ilhan Omar (D-MN)
One of the curriculum’s principal authors, Nabil Sadoun, was deported in 2010 after concealing Hamas connections on immigration paperwork, according to reporting cited by the Middle East Forum.
These were textbooks produced by the organization operating an American school, presenting religious outsiders in hostile terms and praising figures associated with Islamist extremism.
And Jewish students are already experiencing hostility in their schools.
When Jewish Students Become Outsiders
California’s Department of Education found instances of discrimination affecting Jewish and Israeli students in Oakland Unified School District. The findings involved school activities, instructional materials and the district’s response to complaints. When the district failed to complete required corrective measures, California sued in March 2026.
In September, an Alameda County judge ordered Oakland Unified to comply with state directives, including antisemitism training and improved procedures for addressing discrimination. The state had determined that Jewish students were being treated unfairly in their own public schools and had to turn to the courts to secure corrective action.
Teaching the Internal Enemy
Eighty-five years after the Farhud, American Jewish institutions are again being publicly identified as enemies, while researchers document troubling educational materials and state authorities intervene over discrimination against Jewish students, funded by foreign governments and promoted by CAIR.
The classroom is where children learn history, citizenship and their place in society. It is also where they can learn suspicion and hostility toward people sitting beside them. The latter is happening right now.
Last week’s Torah portion, Chayei Sarah, described Abraham burying his beloved wife Sarah in the Cave of Machpelah in Hebron. In his grief, he insisted on purchasing the land at full price, securing a permanent resting place for his family in the land they called home.
This week’s portion, Toldot, moves from land for the dead to water for the living.
After Abraham’s death, the Philistines filled the wells he had dug. His son Isaac, facing hostility and pressure to leave the land, refused to abandon his father’s legacy. He reopened the wells, and the Torah adds an important detail: “He called them by the names that his father had called them.” (Genesis 26:18)
The medieval commentators Rashbam (1085-1158) and Abarbanel (1437-1508) recognized the significance of Isaac’s actions: preserving Abraham’s claims to the wells while resisting efforts to drive his descendants away.
Isaac’s servants then dug new wells, encountering further opposition. He named the first Esek (contention) and the second Sitnah (hostility). When they finally found water that nobody contested, he named the well Rehovot, thanking God for making room for his family to prosper.
Isaac preserved his father’s names and gave his own wells names that recorded the struggles of his generation. He would neither surrender the past nor disguise the present.
Well from 1,500 years ago near Tel Aviv (photo credit: Hami Shif, Israel Antiquities Authority)
Names carry history. They connect people to places, preserve their accomplishments and record their struggles. When those names are erased or replaced, generations can lose their connection to the people who came before them.
For thousands of years, Jews have faced efforts to rename their places, challenge their history and deny their connection to their ancestral homeland. Isaac’s determination remains a lesson for every generation that inherits this history.
Abraham secured a place for Sarah to rest. Isaac secured the water his children would need to live. Neither would allow others to determine whether their family belonged in the land.
The graves of our ancestors and the lives of their descendants are chapters of the same history. We owe it to both to preserve their names, defend their legacy and ensure that the story continues.
Randi Weingarten, president of the 1.8-million-member American Federation of Teachers (AFT), was celebrating Democratic electoral victories. Her social media post praised political organizing and the role of labor unions in getting candidates elected.
There was no mention of students, reading, mathematics or educational achievement.
Weingarten’s enthusiasm makes sense. Teachers’ unions collect dues, organize voters, support political candidates and lobby elected officials. Those officials influence school budgets, employment contracts, staffing rules and teacher accountability.
The unions help elect politicians who subsequently make decisions affecting the unions’ members.
Consider four states: Connecticut, New Jersey, New York and Florida.
CT
NJ
NY
FL
Governor’s party
D
D
D
R
Teachers in unions
97.7%
97.0%
96.6%
58.1%
The three northeast Democratic-governed states have nearly universal teachers’ union membership. Republican-governed Florida has substantially less.
What do those unions secure for their members?
Higher Pay and More Teachers
CT
NJ
NY
FL
Average teacher salary
$89,593
$84,974
$98,655
$56,663
Students per teacher
11.9
11.8
11.6
18.4
New York teachers earn approximately 74% more than Florida teachers. New York also employs approximately 59% more teachers relative to its student population.
Some of the salary difference reflects the higher cost of living in the Northeast. But the staffing difference is substantial. New York maintains roughly 86 teachers for every 1,000 students, compared with 54 in Florida. Higher salaries and more teachers per student are attractive benefits for educators.
What Happens When the Students Leave?
Public-school enrollment has declined across much of the Northeast. New York alone lost more than 165,000 students between 2019 and 2024.
One might expect the teaching workforce to decline alongside enrollment.
Five-year change
CT
NJ
NY
FL
Student enrollment
−2.9%
−1.2%
−6.1%
~0%
Teacher staffing
+1.5%
+0.7%
+0.5%
−6.1%
New York lost 165,000 students and ADDED teachers.
Connecticut and New Jersey also increased teaching staff despite declining enrollment. Florida maintained approximately the same student enrollment while reducing teacher staffing by 6.1%.
Teachers’ unions have an obvious interest in preserving teaching positions. For taxpayers, maintaining staffing while enrollment falls can mean paying more per remaining student.
And New York taxpayers are paying considerably more.
Follow the Money
Annual spending
CT
NJ
NY
FL
Per student
$26,316
$27,234
$31,918
$12,693
New York spends $19,225 more per student every year than Florida, approximately 151% more, due to many more teachers per student and much higher salaries for teachers.
These figures include salaries, benefits, administration, transportation and other operating expenses. They exclude major capital construction and are not adjusted for regional living costs.
One might wonder whether New York is educating a much more challenging student population.
Are the Students Different?
Poverty and English-language proficiency affect educational outcomes. Schools serving disadvantaged students frequently require additional resources.
Student demographics
CT
NJ
NY
FL
English-language learners
9.4%
8.2%
9.7%
9.5%
Low-income students*
41.9%
36.1%
57.1%
~54%
New York and Florida have similar reported percentages of English-language learners and economically disadvantaged students. Meanwhile, New Jersey has lower percentages of both, which may help explain some of its stronger academic performance.
The student populations are hardly identical, but the demographic figures offer little obvious explanation for New York spending two and a half times as much as Florida.
What Do Students Get for the Money?
The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) provides standardized mathematics and reading examinations across states, allowing direct comparisons of academic performance.
Here are the 2024 results.
NAEP average score
CT
NJ
NY
FL
4th-grade math
239
240
234
243
4th-grade reading
219
222
215
218
8th-grade math
277
282
271
267
8th-grade reading
263
266
257
253
Florida outperforms New York in both fourth-grade subjects, despite spending less than half as much per student. By eighth grade, New York pulls ahead, but only by four points in mathematics and four points in reading. New Jersey leads three of the four categories while spending approximately 15% less per student than New York.
New York spends two and a half times as much as Florida, yet its students score worse in fourth grade and only modestly better in eighth.
The Political Machine Keeps Humming
Teachers’ unions secure higher salaries, more teachers per student and job protections. They help elect politicians who approve the budgets and laws sustaining those benefits.
In New York, students leave, teachers stay, and taxpayers continue funding one of the nation’s most expensive public-school systems, with little corresponding academic advantage.
Weingarten concluded her post by promising to tackle the issues weighing on families, including “affordability.”
Perhaps she should start with the teachers’ unions. Their demands contribute to the school spending and property-tax burdens making life less affordable for the very families she claims to champion.
Sources and data notes: Teacher union membership is from the 2020–21 federal teacher survey, as reported by the Thomas B. Fordham Institute. Per-pupil spending is from the U.S. Census Bureau, FY2024. Teacher salaries are from the National Education Association, 2024–25. Enrollment and teacher staffing changes are from federal education data for fall 2019–2024. NAEP scores are from the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress. English-language learner percentages are from NCES. Student-teacher ratios refer to full-time-equivalent teachers, not classroom size.
Low-income figures use school-meal eligibility as a proxy and are drawn from different reporting periods. Florida’s approximate figure and full cross-state comparability remain to be verified before publication.