The Return of the Jew Hunt

In October 2023, a mob stormed an airport in Dagestan, Russia, searching for Jews arriving on a flight from Israel. Rioters raced onto the tarmac, surrounded aircraft and demanded to know where the Jews were. A day earlier, another mob had searched a hotel in the region following rumors that Israelis were staying there.

That same month, protesters outside the Sydney Opera House chanted, “Where’s the Jews?” In New York, Jewish students at Cooper Union sheltered behind locked library doors as demonstrators banged on the glass. A year later, Israeli soccer supporters were chased and beaten through the streets of Amsterdam in attacks described as a “Jew hunt.“

The incidents were different, but the intimidation was unmistakable. Jews were being sought out, threatened and, in some cases, physically attacked. Others were seeking shelter.

Eighty years earlier, another Jewish family was hiding in Amsterdam.

Anne Frank spent more than two years concealed in a secret annex. She could not attend school, walk outside or reveal her presence to neighbors. Her family depended on courageous people willing to risk their own safety to keep them hidden.

Anne Frank was not hiding from the general dangers of World War II. She was hiding because she was Jewish, and people were hunting Jews.

The Nazis understood the power of fear. Their campaign began with demonization, public humiliation, boycotts and exclusion. Jews were driven from professions, universities, businesses and public life. They were identified, isolated and eventually hunted down for deportation and murder.

The hunt was not incidental to the Holocaust. It was essential to its execution. Authorities compiled lists, searched homes, checked identification papers and recruited collaborators to locate Jews who had escaped. Those who could not flee attempted to disappear.

Anne Frank’s family was discovered in August 1944. She was killed in Bergen-Belsen.

Her diary became one of the world’s most widely read accounts of the Holocaust. Yet Anne Frank has also become a universal symbol of innocent suffering, sometimes obscuring why she was persecuted.

In 2016, New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof published “Anne Frank Today Is a Syrian Girl,” comparing her with a child wounded in Syria’s civil war. This is preposterous. Anne Frank was not simply a child caught in a war. She was hunted because she was Jewish. Her identity alone marked her for deportation and death.

This raises a question about what Holocaust education teaches. And how it gets abused.

Anti-Israel protestor mocking the memory of Anne Frank, attempting to turn Israel into modern day Nazis

We teach children about six million murdered Jews, Auschwitz, gas chambers, Nazi propaganda and the dangers of indifference. We explain how Jews were demonized as dangerous, disloyal and responsible for society’s problems.

But the Nazis did not merely want Jews to be hated. They wanted Jews removed from society, first through exclusion and forced emigration, and ultimately through extermination. The identification and hunt was the means to affect a genocide.

There is a contemporary dimension to this history that deserves attention.

When demonstrators declare that Zionists are unwelcome in public spaces, the question becomes whether Jewish identity or support for Israel is being used to exclude people from ordinary civic life. When protesters chant “Globalize the Intifada,” the slogan takes on a more threatening significance when accompanied by assaults, intimidation or the pursuit of Jews.

Massachusetts “mapping project” of local Jewish organizations

The physical hunt is the most visible expression of a broader pattern of intimidation. The threat of being identified and targeted can accomplish something even without an assault: Jews begin to withdraw. They avoid demonstrations, conceal religious symbols, reconsider attending public events or seek protection simply to move through places where everyone else can go freely.

In May 2021, Aaron Keyak, who served in the Biden administration as Jewish liaison and deputy special envoy to monitor and combat antisemitism, advised American Jews: “It pains me to say this, but if you fear for your life or physical safety take off your kippah and hide your magen david.”

Consider what that advice means.

A Jew should remove a kippah before walking down the street. A Star of David should disappear beneath a shirt. Jewish identity becomes something to conceal for personal safety. Discourage participation in public life and make ordinary freedoms feel dangerous.

This is why the search for Jews deserves greater attention in Holocaust education. The persecution of European Jewry was not simply a matter of hateful beliefs culminating in six million murders. It involved a systematic campaign to identify Jews, remove them from public life and pursue those who attempted to escape.

When individuals search for Jews, pursue them through streets or threaten them into hiding, the conduct should be recognized for what it is.

Nerdeen Kiswani of Within Our Lifetime calls for the complete destruction of the Jewish State and “US imperialism” as a direct calling from Allah, and urges finding and confronting Zionists, “KNOW YOUR ENEMY“

We have spent generations teaching children where Anne Frank hid and what happened when she was discovered. We should also teach them what it means when people go looking for Jews—and when Jews once again feel compelled to disappear from public view.

The Price of an Illinois Boycott Victory

The Palestinian Authority’s official news agency, WAFA, celebrated a victory in Illinois this week. After more than two years of protests and political pressure, activists claimed credit for the state’s decision not to renew $10 million in Israeli government bonds.

But what did that victory accomplish, and at what potential cost to Illinois taxpayers?

Illinois State Treasurer Michael Frerichs, a Democrat, oversees approximately $41.6 billion in state investments. Earlier this year, $100 million was invested in Israel Bonds, less than one-quarter of one percent of the portfolio.

When $20 million matured in November, Illinois renewed $10 million and allowed the other $10 million to mature without renewal. The state continues to hold $90 million in Israel Bonds, approximately 0.22% of its portfolio. The reduction celebrated by WAFA represents just 0.024% of Illinois’s total investments.

Yet those bonds have been among the state’s most profitable investments.

The newly renewed five-year Israel Bonds pay 6.17%, the highest rate Illinois has received in 25 years. That is 1.24 percentage points above comparable U.S. Treasury securities and higher than indicative five-year sovereign yields from Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates. On $10 million, the premium over comparable U.S. Treasuries represents $124,000 in additional annual interest, or $620,000 over five years.

Frerichs himself has acknowledged that Israel Bonds have consistently delivered among the highest returns in the state’s portfolio over the past two decades. His office has also emphasized Israel’s record of meeting its principal and interest obligations.

The same month, Frerichs announced an additional $50 million investment in Polish government bonds, increasing Illinois’s Polish holdings to $65 million. Half of the new investment pays 4.875% for four years, while the other half pays 4.625% for five years.

Diversification across sovereign borrowers is a legitimate investment strategy. Illinois also has a substantial Polish-American community, which Frerichs acknowledged when announcing the purchase. But Poland’s bonds pay considerably less than Israel’s.

If Illinois redirected the $10 million from Israel Bonds yielding 6.17% into Polish bonds yielding an average of 4.75%, the state would collect approximately $142,000 less in annual interest. That is nearly the annual salary of two public school teachers. Every year for five years.

In an election year dominated by affordability, taxes and the cost of living, the possibility of sacrificing investment income raises a question about the financial priorities of state government.

There is also a political context.

BDS Chicago, the U.S. Palestinian Community Network, the Chicago Anti-War Committee and the Illinois Divestment Network have spent more than two years organizing demonstrations, petitions and political pressure demanding that Frerichs eliminate the state’s investments in Israel Bonds.

Their campaign extends beyond the treasury portfolio. In 2015, Illinois became the first state to adopt legislation restricting state pension investments in companies that boycott Israel. The activists want that law repealed.

In the November 3 elections, voters in eight Illinois municipalities and townships approved nonbinding measures opposing the legislation. Although the votes did not change state law, organizers celebrated them as progress toward their broader objective of ending Illinois’s financial support for Israel.

Whether the activists actually influenced Frerichs’s investment decision remains unknown. Diversification, liquidity requirements or another investment opportunity may explain why he renewed only half the maturing bonds.

But the treasurer has not publicly explained where the remaining $10 million went or why its new investment was preferable to renewing Israel Bonds at 6.17%.

Illinois taxpayers can seek that answer directly.

Illinois State Treasurer Michael Frerichs, Media contact: Eric Krol — 312-814-1252

Call the Illinois treasurer to find out if anti-Israel activists have cost the state two teacher salaries.

The New York Times Makes Israel the Threat

Iran is rebuilding its missile and drone arsenals, expanding its chemical and biological weapons capabilities, and reportedly plotting attacks against senior American officials.

The New York Times has identified the problem: Israel.

“Trump Weighs New Strikes on Iran as Israel Presses for Action,” declares its headline. Israel is “pressing hard,” “intensifying pressure,” “pushing plans” and “seeking to convince” Washington to attack. Its intelligence is reduced to “warnings,” “assertions,” “suggestions” and “claims.”

Yet the newspaper acknowledges that American intelligence officials independently see evidence of Iran expanding its chemical and biological weapons capabilities. It also reports Israeli intelligence concerning possible Iranian chemical attacks against senior American officials, including a threat reportedly connected to Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent being moved from his home.

One might imagine these revelations would command the headline and the lead of the story.

Instead, the Times turns to Benjamin Netanyahu’s political survival, declaring that his push for another round of strikes is “inextricably tied to his fight for political survival.”

Iran’s weapons programs become the backdrop. Netanyahu’s motives become the story.

Iran is developing dangerous weapons capabilities, Israel is warning America about the threat, and the New York Times directs its scrutiny toward the country sounding the alarm rather than the regime giving cause for it.

Pew’s Canadian Jewish Forecast Doesn’t Add Up

The Pew Research Center released a sweeping study this week projecting the world’s religious populations through 2070. Israel’s Jewish population is expected to surge, France’s to collapse, and America’s to decline.

But Canada is apparently about to experience a Jewish renaissance.

Pew projects Canada’s Jewish population will grow from 350,000 in 2020 to 500,000 in 2070, a remarkable 43% increase.

The problem is how Pew gets there.

Its own demographic model breaks down the projected growth:

SourcePopulation change
Births minus deaths+60,000
Net migration−30,000
Religious switching+130,000

Canada accounts for barely 2% of world Jewry, yet Pew assigns it nearly 24% of the world’s projected net gains from religious switching. Even the United States, with sixteen times Canada’s Jewish population, is projected to gain only 140,000 net Jewish religious switchers.

Meanwhile, Canadian Jews are facing unprecedented antisemitism. Jews represent approximately 1% of Canada’s population but accounted for 68% of religiously motivated hate crimes in 2024. Synagogues and Jewish schools have been attacked, and Jewish children have concealed their identities to avoid harassment.

Pew acknowledges that it lacks reliable Canadian Jewish retention data. Nevertheless, its model assumes everyone raised Jewish remains Jewish while allowing others to switch into Judaism.

Canadian Jews may celebrate that Pew forecasts that there will be half a million Jews in the country by 2070, more than any country outside of Israel and the United States. Alas, the analysis seems deeply flawed. I suggest they consider how to actively build a strong and vibrant Jewish life which does not have magical numbers of converts joining the ranks.

A People of Many Lands With One Homeland

The Jewish people have spent much of their history outside the Land of Israel. They built extraordinary communities, raised generations of children, accumulated wealth and contributed to civilizations across the world. Some communities flourished for centuries. Others vanished.

Yet their homeland never changed.

This paradox appears in Vayetzei, at the beginning of the Jewish people’s formation.

Abraham secured a burial place in the Promised Land. Isaac reopened his father’s wells to sustain life there. But Jacob, whose twelve sons would become the tribes of Israel, built almost his entire family in Haran, far from the land promised to his fathers.

Eleven of his twelve sons were born there. Despite Laban’s deception and hostility, Jacob prospered, establishing a family and acquiring considerable wealth. Twenty years later, God commanded him to return.

Jacob was not returning because he had failed abroad. He was returning after succeeding.

The pattern continued in Egypt. Jacob’s extended family of seventy descended into Egypt, where their descendants multiplied into a nation numbering hundreds of thousands. Their greatest population growth occurred outside their homeland, yet their national journey led back to the land promised to their ancestors.

Centuries later, Jewish communities flourished in Babylon, Spain, Poland, Britain, America and countless other places. They created centers of learning, commerce and culture, often becoming deeply attached to their adopted countries.

But prosperity abroad never erased their connection to their ancestral homeland.

The diaspora was not simply an interruption of Jewish history. It was one of its great engines of growth, beginning with Jacob himself.

Hamas’s Hero Fought Two Wars. Only One Ended.

Ninety-one years ago today, on November 20, 1935, British police killed Izz ad-Din al-Qassam in a gun battle near Jenin. His jihad began against European imperial powers. In Palestine, it also became a war against Jews seeking to rebuild their homeland.

Izz ad-din al-Qassam (1882-1935)

Al-Qassam was born in 1882 in Jableh, Syria, then part of the Ottoman Empire. He studied Islamic theology at al-Azhar in Cairo and became a militant preacher advocating jihad against foreign powers in Muslim lands.

When Italy invaded Libya in 1911, he raised money and recruited volunteers to fight the Italians. He later joined armed “resistance” against the French in Syria, earning a death sentence. In 1920, he fled to Haifa, two years before the League of Nations formally approved the British Mandate for Palestine.

Al-Qassam brought two causes to Palestine.

The first was expelling European powers from Arab and Muslim lands: Italy in Libya, France in Syria and now Britain in Palestine. Today, this would be called anti-colonialism.

The second was preventing Jews from reestablishing their national homeland.

Jews were not Italians in Libya or Frenchmen in Syria. Jews are an ancient, land-based people whose religion, identity and history are rooted in the Land of Israel. Jewish communities had lived there continuously for millennia, while generations in the diaspora prayed and yearned to return.

Jews at the Kotel, the Western Wall of the Jewish Temple Mount in the 1870s

One cause opposed foreign imperial rule. The other sought to deny Jews the very national rights he claimed for Arabs.

In Haifa, al-Qassam recruited followers and organized clandestine armed cells. By the early 1930s, he had established the Black Hand, a militant network that targeted Jewish communities and opposed British rule.

On November 7, 1935, Jewish police sergeant Moshe Rosenfeld was killed near Ein Harod in an attack attributed to al-Qassam’s armed group. Later that month, al-Qassam took his followers into the hills near Ya’bad to wage jihad.

British authorities pursued the group. Surrounded on November 20, al-Qassam reportedly refused surrender, declaring that he was fighting a holy war for God and the homeland. Al-Qassam and several followers were killed, along with a British policeman. Thousands attended his funeral. He became a celebrated martyr.

Five months later, on April 15, 1936, militants associated with al-Qassam’s movement attacked Jewish motorists near Tulkarm. Historical accounts describe the attackers invoking revenge for his death and seeking money for weapons. They shot three Jewish passengers, killing two.

The British killed al-Qassam. His followers killed Jews to avenge him.

The murders helped ignite the Arab Revolt of 1936–1939, during which Jews and British authorities were targeted in a sustained campaign of violence.

Hamas eventually named its military wing after al-Qassam. Palestinian Authority schools have borne his name supported by European funds, and activists in Sweden advertised a gathering honoring him as recently as November 2025.

The Izz al-Din al-Qassam Brigades (IQB) was founded in 1991 as the military wing of Hamas

Al-Qassam died before Israel existed. Before anyone called Judea and Samaria the “West Bank.” Before there was an Israeli occupation to oppose.

In 1948, Britain left Palestine and with it, the European imperial rule he had fought. But the other war did not end.

The colonial power departed nearly eight decades ago. The Arab war against Jewish sovereignty in their ancestral homeland continues.

Artificial Intelligence and Depiction of Jews

I have written nearly 2,400 articles on FirstOneThrough since starting the blog, totaling 1.8 million words. Together, they form a continuous chronicle of modern Jewry—its challenges, controversies and battles—written by a single author.

So why are people in China suddenly reading them?

Google Analytics shows traffic from Beijing and Shanghai, but also Wenzhou, Jinzhong, Enshi, Jiujiang, Huanggang, Hezhou, Yichun and dozens of other Chinese cities. Singapore and Hong Kong have also become significant sources of traffic.

Perhaps FirstOneThrough has developed a large Chinese following. Unlikely.

More curious is what these visitors are reading. They aren’t concentrating on recent articles about Israel or China. They are visiting old articles scattered throughout the site’s history, typically one view per article, moving through years of material.

It looks less like people reading a blog than machines reading a library.

I cannot establish that these are artificial intelligence crawlers. They could be search engines, data collectors or other automated systems. The geographic locations may simply reflect where servers are located.

But the possibility raises a much bigger question.

What happens when the audience for our writing is no longer just people, but the machines that will answer their questions?

The New Readers

Artificial intelligence needs enormous amounts of information. Books, newspapers, websites, academic papers, government records, Wikipedia, Reddit and millions of blogs provide the raw material from which AI systems learn.

FirstOneThrough is a tiny part of that universe. But a continuous account of modern Jewish life, written over many years and covering a concentrated set of subjects, may be valuable to machines assembling information about Jews and Israel.

Why wouldn’t a machine read it?

For years, I assumed that someone interested in Jerusalem, antisemitism or Jewish history might search Google and find an article or a video on YouTube. Whether the person would agree or disagree with the information or opinion, at least he would encounter it.

That model is changing.

People increasingly ask AI to explain Zionism, the 1948 war, Palestinian Arab “refugees”, Jewish claims to Jerusalem or the October 7 massacre. Instead of reviewing competing articles, they receive a neatly assembled answer.

And they may never know which sources influenced it.

The battle over information is moving from the websites people visit to the machines people trust.

Who Writes the Answers?

Consider the endless battles over Wikipedia. Activists fight over whether Hamas members are described as terrorists or militants, whether Jerusalem is characterized as occupied territory, and which historical accounts are considered reliable.

People have been fighting over what people read on Wikipedia. The greater battle may be over what machines learn from it.

Wikipedia is widely used in developing and informing AI systems. So are newspapers, academic research and countless other online sources. Arguments that once shaped individual webpages can now influence the information systems that millions of people consult.

Of course, a single article doesn’t dictate an AI response. Different systems use different training material, retrieval tools and methods of evaluating information. But the larger principle is obvious: information that is accessible to machines has an opportunity to influence their answers. Information that remains inaccessible does not.

And therein lies a serious challenge for Jews.

Als Höhepunkt einer von Joseph Goebbels initiierten ‘Aktion wider den undeutschen Geist’ werden auf dem Opernplatz in Berlin von Studenten und SA-Einheiten Bücher von Autoren verbrannt, die den Nationalsozialisten mißliebig waren.

The Jewish Library

Jews have spent thousands of years recording their history, laws, arguments, prayers and experiences. We are called the People of the Book for good reason.

Yet how much of that extraordinary library is available to the machines increasingly explaining Jewish history to the world?

Holocaust testimonies sit in archives. Historical documents remain in filing cabinets. Important scholarship exists only in Hebrew. Old newspapers are preserved as scanned images. Archaeological reports, government records and primary-source material may be technically online but difficult to discover or search.

Meanwhile, activists publish thousands of easily accessible articles, social media posts and Wikipedia edits, many deeply hostile to the Jewish State and Jews everywhere.

The machines cannot be expected to weigh evidence they cannot find.

The Jewish response should be straightforward. Digitize Jewish archives. Translate historical documents. Make scholarship searchable. Publish original sources about Jewish communities in Arab and Muslim lands, the history of Jerusalem, the Holocaust, and the modern State of Israel. Make sure the AI engines know about the library.

Rabbi at the National Library
Rabbi at Israel’s National Library (photo: First One Through)

Put the evidence where the machines can find it.

And keep writing.

The Next Battle

For decades, Jewish organizations have fought over newspaper coverage, university curricula, textbooks and television reporting. More recently, the battlefield expanded to Wikipedia and social media.

Artificial intelligence adds another front, potentially more consequential than all the others.

A student researching Israel, a journalist investigating antisemitism or a politician seeking background on Jerusalem may never consult a Jewish archive or open a history book. They may simply ask a machine and receive an answer in seconds, carrying an appearance of neutrality and authority regardless of whether the underlying information deserves either.

Who will have supplied that information?

I don’t know whether the visitors from China are collecting FirstOneThrough articles for artificial intelligence. Maybe they are doing something entirely different.

But the prospect of machines daily working through the First One Through collection is intriguing. I wrote those pieces to put facts, arguments and perspectives into the public record, assuming people would eventually find them.

Perhaps machines are finding them now, and people will become a smaller share of the viewership.

The Jewish people have spent thousands of years preserving their books for their internal use, often defying those who would destroy them. Now we must make sure the next generation of readers – human and artificial – can find them.

Will British Jewry Be Unrecognizable – Or Highly Recognizable – by 2040?

British Jews are increasingly questioning whether they have a future in Britain. Yet by 2040, Britain could have more Jews than it does today.

The apparent contradiction reflects a demographic transformation already underway. One segment of British Jewry is growing rapidly, while another has barely grown in two decades and is increasingly questioning whether to remain.

In 2001, Haredi Jews represented roughly one in eight Jews in England and Wales. By 2021, they accounted for nearly one in four. Today, they represent approximately 26% of Britain’s estimated 315,000 Jews (0.4% – 0.5% of the total UK population). The Haredi population nearly doubled in twenty years, while the rest of British Jewry remained virtually unchanged.

England and Wales20012021
Haredi Jews37,00073,000
Other Jews239,000237,000
Haredi share13%24%

The difference is largely explained by children. Haredi families commonly have five, six or more, and their communities are exceptionally young. Today, 60% of pupils attending British Jewish schools are in strictly Orthodox schools. Those children will become the next generation of parents, carrying forward a demographic expansion already embedded in the population.

While Haredi families are raising the next generation of British Jews, growing numbers of other British Jews are questioning whether to raise theirs in Britain at all.

Haredi Jews in the UK

A December 2025 survey by the Campaign Against Antisemitism found that 61% of respondents had considered leaving Britain because of antisemitism. Only 23% believed Jews had a long-term future in the country. The survey relied on self-selected respondents, but the depth of concern among those surveyed is difficult to dismiss.

Separate research by the Institute for Jewish Policy Research found that approximately 6% of British Jews surveyed in 2024 considered themselves highly likely to move permanently to Israel within five years. More recent JPR research found that younger Jews, Orthodox Jews and those most affected by antisemitism were particularly likely to consider aliyah.

And some are already leaving.

British aliyah to Israel has averaged roughly 550 people annually over the past two decades. In calendar 2025, 742 made aliyah, the highest annual total in more than forty years. During the Jewish year ending in 2026, Israeli authorities reported 975 immigrants from Britain, another forty-year high.

Those numbers represent a small percentage of the country’s Jews (0.3%) and a sustained exodus has not yet been established. Nevertheless, the latest figures suggest that growing emigration concerns may be beginning to translate into action.

Israel is only one destination. British Jews also have family, professional and communal ties to the United States, Canada, Australia and elsewhere. Those departures are harder to count because immigration records in those countries generally do not identify religion.

Nor would it take a mass departure to change British Jewry. A net decline of just 10% of today’s approximately 233,000 non-Haredi Jews over the next fourteen years would represent 23,300 people, equivalent to fewer than 1,700 annually. With historical Haredi growth continuing, that alone would raise the projected Haredi share in 2040 from approximately 36% to nearly 39%.

But the most intriguing twist comes from Israel itself.

For British Jews alarmed by antisemitism, Israel offers a Jewish homeland where they can build a future without depending on the tolerance of a non-Jewish majority. For some Haredi families, however, Israel presents a different calculation.

The Jewish state is struggling over compulsory military service for Haredi men. Israel’s Supreme Court has ruled against the continuation of broad exemptions without legal authorization, and the issue remains deeply contested politically. For British Haredi families opposed to conscription, uncertainty about whether their sons might face military obligations could discourage aliyah. The effect would depend on immigrant eligibility rules and future legislation; there is not yet evidence establishing that it is influencing British Haredi migration decisions.

English-speaking ultra-Orthodox rabbis hold an anti-conscription event in Ramat Beit Shemesh, December 22, 2025. (Sam Sokol/Times of Israel)

The irony is striking. Israel may increasingly attract British Jews who fear antisemitism, while its military conscription controversy could discourage some Haredi families from leaving Britain.

Meanwhile, established Haredi communities in UK’s Stamford Hill, Golders Green, Manchester and beyond provide the schools, synagogues and religious institutions needed to sustain large and growing families.

The result could be a growing divergence within British Jewry, with some Jews increasingly looking abroad while its fastest-growing segment has strong reasons to remain.

Qatar’s al Jazeera video on Haredi community in England ignoring COVID regulations

What would that mean by 2040?

The Institute for Jewish Policy Research has suggested that Haredim could approach one-third of British Jewry by 2040. My analysis suggests that the proportion could be higher, with 40% a plausible intermediate outcome rather than necessarily an upper boundary.

Starting with approximately 82,000 Haredi and 233,000 other Jews today, simply extending historical Haredi population growth of 3.5% annually, with no decline in the rest of British Jewry, produces a Haredi share of approximately 36% by 2040. A modest contraction in the non-Haredi population, combined with somewhat faster Haredi expansion, moves the share toward 40%. More pronounced changes could push it closer to 43%.

2040 scenarioHaredi JewsOther JewsHaredi share
Historical continuity133,000233,00036%
Moderate shift140,000220,00039%
Accelerated shift146,000197,00043%
These are illustrative scenarios, not probability-weighted forecasts. The historical case assumes 3.5% annual Haredi growth and a stable non-Haredi population. The moderate case assumes approximately 3.9% Haredi growth and 0.4% annual non-Haredi decline. The accelerated case assumes approximately 4.2% Haredi growth and 1.2% annual non-Haredi decline.

By 2040, Haredim could represent more than two in five British Jews, reshaping the country’s Jewish schools, synagogues, institutions and relationship with Israel.

The transformation requires no mass exodus. But it could accelerate if Jews questioning their future in Britain begin leaving, while Israeli conscription politics discourage some Haredi families from following.

Britain could have more Jews in 2040 than it has today. But the British Jewry behind those numbers may be profoundly different.


Sources

1. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Historical British Jewish demographics

New Trends in the Study of Haredi Culture and Society, demographic analysis, Table 4. Documents Haredi and non-Haredi population estimates for England and Wales in 2001, 2011 and 2021.

2. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Haredi population estimates

Dr. Daniel Staetsky, Haredi Jews around the world: Population trends and estimates, May 2022. Establishes the demographic characteristics and historical growth rates of Haredi populations.

3. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Updated population estimates

JPR presentation, March 2026. Reports a UK core Jewish population of approximately 315,000, including 82,000 Haredi Jews, representing 26%.

4. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Jewish school enrollment

Five interesting facts about Jewish schools in the UK. Reports that 60% of Jewish pupils attending Jewish schools are enrolled in strictly Orthodox schools.

5. Campaign Against Antisemitism — British Jewish attitudes

New polling: Majority of British Jews see no future in UK, December 21, 2025. Survey of 4,490 respondents, including questions about emigration, antisemitism and the future of Jewish life in Britain.

6. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — Emigration and aliyah

Dr. Jonathan Boyd, Time to leave the UK? Patterns of Jewish migration to Israel post-October 7, April 20, 2026. Examines annual aliyah figures, historical averages, emigration intentions and migration limitations.

7. Times of Israel — 2026 aliyah figures

Some 20,000 immigrated to Israel since last Rosh Hashanah as Western aliyah rises, September 2026. Reports 975 immigrants from Britain during the Jewish year.

8. Institute for Jewish Policy Research — 2040 British demographic outlook

Dr. Jonathan Boyd, One in seven of all Jews are strictly Orthodox; by 2040, it will be one in five, June 18, 2022. Discusses the expectation that Britain’s Haredi proportion could approach one-third by 2040.

9. Library of Congress — Israeli Haredi conscription

Israel: High Court Imposes Sanctions on Individual Haredi Men Avoiding Draft, July 1, 2026. Summarizes Israeli Supreme Court rulings and enforcement obligations.

10. Israel Democracy Institute — Conscription controversy

Conscription of Haredi Yeshiva Students to the IDF and the Emerging Constitutional Crisis, January 21, 2026. Explains the legal and political conflict surrounding Haredi military service.

11. FirstOneThrough — Independent 2040 demographic scenarios

Author’s calculations using the JPR March 2026 population estimates as the starting point, with compound annual population growth and decline assumptions over fourteen years. These scenarios are independent illustrations, not published JPR forecasts.

Europe’s Erasure of Jewish Jerusalem

Jews were already the majority of Jerusalem’s population since the 1860s, over half a century before the Balfour Declaration and the British Mandate. Even within the Old City, roughly one-quarter of its recorded Ottoman subjects were Jewish in 1900. Their synagogues, schools, homes and religious institutions were woven into Jerusalem’s life long before the modern State of Israel.

Yet for the last two decades, the European Union has spent millions of euros preserving Jerusalem’s so-called “Palestinian heritage,” with no comparable funding identified for Jewish institutions in the Old City.

In 2013, the EU committed €2.4 million to restoring Islamic baths, a madrasa and other historic buildings. It later provided €4.23 million to rehabilitate a Franciscan-owned property for Palestinian housing and community use. In 2019, the EU awarded another €1.18 million to a project explicitly titled “Protecting Islamic and Christian Cultural Heritage in Jerusalem.”

No money has been spent on preserving Jewish heritage. By design.

In 1948, Jordanian forces captured the Jewish Quarter, expelled its Jewish residents and destroyed or desecrated its synagogues. For nineteen years, Jews were barred from entering the Old City. The Hurva Synagogue lay in ruins for decades.

A lone arch stood in the place of the destroyed Hurva Synagogue, until Israel rebuilt it with its own funds in 2010 (photo: First One Through in 1996)

Europe finances the preservation of Jerusalem’s Islamic and Christian heritage while offering no comparable support for the Jewish institutions that survived that destruction at the hands of Arabs.

The issue is not about Israel’s sovereignty. It is the Jewish people’s history, religion and connection to their holiest city.

The EU is not merely taking sides in a territorial dispute. By selectively funding non-Jewish Jerusalem’s heritage, it has become complicit in the erasure of Jews from the historical and cultural identity of their own holiest city.

The Grocery Bill Is Only a Problem When the Money Goes to Jews

Imagine Cenk Uygur filming his grocery-store commercial in Paris.

Man in a suit speaking into a microphone on a brightly lit stage

French families struggle to afford groceries. Violent riots have shaken major cities. Government debt is soaring, public services are strained, and officials insist there is no money for higher wages.

Yet France just committed another $5.5 million to build infrastructure for Palestinian Arabs in Judea and Samaria.

On November 17, as 146,000 demonstrators protested wages and deteriorating services, France pledged €5 million for Palestinian roads, electricity, water and other infrastructure in disputed territory. Just days earlier, Cenk Uygur blamed France’s riots on unaffordability, Israel and Zionists. He has said nothing about France sending money to Palestinian Arabs.

Of course, $5.5 million won’t rescue France’s finances. Neither would eliminating American aid to Israel make groceries affordable. But that never troubled Uygur’s argument.

The problem was never foreign aid. It was aid to Jews.

Screenshot of a post by Cenk Uygur stating, “If Jesus was born in Bethlehem today, he would be a Palestinian.”
Stupidity from the mouth of an antisemite. If my grandmother had wheels she’d be a wagon.