The Price of an Illinois Boycott Victory

The Palestinian Authority’s official news agency, WAFA, celebrated a victory in Illinois this week. After more than two years of protests and political pressure, activists claimed credit for the state’s decision not to renew $10 million in Israeli government bonds.

But what did that victory accomplish, and at what potential cost to Illinois taxpayers?

Illinois State Treasurer Michael Frerichs, a Democrat, oversees approximately $41.6 billion in state investments. Earlier this year, $100 million was invested in Israel Bonds, less than one-quarter of one percent of the portfolio.

When $20 million matured in November, Illinois renewed $10 million and allowed the other $10 million to mature without renewal. The state continues to hold $90 million in Israel Bonds, approximately 0.22% of its portfolio. The reduction celebrated by WAFA represents just 0.024% of Illinois’s total investments.

Yet those bonds have been among the state’s most profitable investments.

The newly renewed five-year Israel Bonds pay 6.17%, the highest rate Illinois has received in 25 years. That is 1.24 percentage points above comparable U.S. Treasury securities and higher than indicative five-year sovereign yields from Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates. On $10 million, the premium over comparable U.S. Treasuries represents $124,000 in additional annual interest, or $620,000 over five years.

Frerichs himself has acknowledged that Israel Bonds have consistently delivered among the highest returns in the state’s portfolio over the past two decades. His office has also emphasized Israel’s record of meeting its principal and interest obligations.

The same month, Frerichs announced an additional $50 million investment in Polish government bonds, increasing Illinois’s Polish holdings to $65 million. Half of the new investment pays 4.875% for four years, while the other half pays 4.625% for five years.

Diversification across sovereign borrowers is a legitimate investment strategy. Illinois also has a substantial Polish-American community, which Frerichs acknowledged when announcing the purchase. But Poland’s bonds pay considerably less than Israel’s.

If Illinois redirected the $10 million from Israel Bonds yielding 6.17% into Polish bonds yielding an average of 4.75%, the state would collect approximately $142,000 less in annual interest. That is nearly the annual salary of two public school teachers. Every year for five years.

In an election year dominated by affordability, taxes and the cost of living, the possibility of sacrificing investment income raises a question about the financial priorities of state government.

There is also a political context.

BDS Chicago, the U.S. Palestinian Community Network, the Chicago Anti-War Committee and the Illinois Divestment Network have spent more than two years organizing demonstrations, petitions and political pressure demanding that Frerichs eliminate the state’s investments in Israel Bonds.

Their campaign extends beyond the treasury portfolio. In 2015, Illinois became the first state to adopt legislation restricting state pension investments in companies that boycott Israel. The activists want that law repealed.

In the November 3 elections, voters in eight Illinois municipalities and townships approved nonbinding measures opposing the legislation. Although the votes did not change state law, organizers celebrated them as progress toward their broader objective of ending Illinois’s financial support for Israel.

Whether the activists actually influenced Frerichs’s investment decision remains unknown. Diversification, liquidity requirements or another investment opportunity may explain why he renewed only half the maturing bonds.

But the treasurer has not publicly explained where the remaining $10 million went or why its new investment was preferable to renewing Israel Bonds at 6.17%.

Illinois taxpayers can seek that answer directly.

Illinois State Treasurer Michael Frerichs, Media contact: Eric Krol — 312-814-1252

Call the Illinois treasurer to find out if anti-Israel activists have cost the state two teacher salaries.

Leave a Reply