The Return of the Jew Hunt

In October 2023, a mob stormed an airport in Dagestan, Russia, searching for Jews arriving on a flight from Israel. Rioters raced onto the tarmac, surrounded aircraft and demanded to know where the Jews were. A day earlier, another mob had searched a hotel in the region following rumors that Israelis were staying there.

That same month, protesters outside the Sydney Opera House chanted, “Where’s the Jews?” In New York, Jewish students at Cooper Union sheltered behind locked library doors as demonstrators banged on the glass. A year later, Israeli soccer supporters were chased and beaten through the streets of Amsterdam in attacks described as a “Jew hunt.“

The incidents were different, but the intimidation was unmistakable. Jews were being sought out, threatened and, in some cases, physically attacked. Others were seeking shelter.

Eighty years earlier, another Jewish family was hiding in Amsterdam.

Anne Frank spent more than two years concealed in a secret annex. She could not attend school, walk outside or reveal her presence to neighbors. Her family depended on courageous people willing to risk their own safety to keep them hidden.

Anne Frank was not hiding from the general dangers of World War II. She was hiding because she was Jewish, and people were hunting Jews.

The Nazis understood the power of fear. Their campaign began with demonization, public humiliation, boycotts and exclusion. Jews were driven from professions, universities, businesses and public life. They were identified, isolated and eventually hunted down for deportation and murder.

The hunt was not incidental to the Holocaust. It was essential to its execution. Authorities compiled lists, searched homes, checked identification papers and recruited collaborators to locate Jews who had escaped. Those who could not flee attempted to disappear.

Anne Frank’s family was discovered in August 1944. She was killed in Bergen-Belsen.

Her diary became one of the world’s most widely read accounts of the Holocaust. Yet Anne Frank has also become a universal symbol of innocent suffering, sometimes obscuring why she was persecuted.

In 2016, New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof published “Anne Frank Today Is a Syrian Girl,” comparing her with a child wounded in Syria’s civil war. This is preposterous. Anne Frank was not simply a child caught in a war. She was hunted because she was Jewish. Her identity alone marked her for deportation and death.

This raises a question about what Holocaust education teaches. And how it gets abused.

Anti-Israel protestor mocking the memory of Anne Frank, attempting to turn Israel into modern day Nazis

We teach children about six million murdered Jews, Auschwitz, gas chambers, Nazi propaganda and the dangers of indifference. We explain how Jews were demonized as dangerous, disloyal and responsible for society’s problems.

But the Nazis did not merely want Jews to be hated. They wanted Jews removed from society, first through exclusion and forced emigration, and ultimately through extermination. The identification and hunt was the means to affect a genocide.

There is a contemporary dimension to this history that deserves attention.

When demonstrators declare that Zionists are unwelcome in public spaces, the question becomes whether Jewish identity or support for Israel is being used to exclude people from ordinary civic life. When protesters chant “Globalize the Intifada,” the slogan takes on a more threatening significance when accompanied by assaults, intimidation or the pursuit of Jews.

Massachusetts “mapping project” of local Jewish organizations

The physical hunt is the most visible expression of a broader pattern of intimidation. The threat of being identified and targeted can accomplish something even without an assault: Jews begin to withdraw. They avoid demonstrations, conceal religious symbols, reconsider attending public events or seek protection simply to move through places where everyone else can go freely.

In May 2021, Aaron Keyak, who served in the Biden administration as Jewish liaison and deputy special envoy to monitor and combat antisemitism, advised American Jews: “It pains me to say this, but if you fear for your life or physical safety take off your kippah and hide your magen david.”

Consider what that advice means.

A Jew should remove a kippah before walking down the street. A Star of David should disappear beneath a shirt. Jewish identity becomes something to conceal for personal safety. Discourage participation in public life and make ordinary freedoms feel dangerous.

This is why the search for Jews deserves greater attention in Holocaust education. The persecution of European Jewry was not simply a matter of hateful beliefs culminating in six million murders. It involved a systematic campaign to identify Jews, remove them from public life and pursue those who attempted to escape.

When individuals search for Jews, pursue them through streets or threaten them into hiding, the conduct should be recognized for what it is.

Nerdeen Kiswani of Within Our Lifetime calls for the complete destruction of the Jewish State and “US imperialism” as a direct calling from Allah, and urges finding and confronting Zionists, “KNOW YOUR ENEMY“

We have spent generations teaching children where Anne Frank hid and what happened when she was discovered. We should also teach them what it means when people go looking for Jews—and when Jews once again feel compelled to disappear from public view.

Leave a Reply