Who Gets to Write the “Nakba”?

CAIR, Teachers’ Unions and the Jewish Homeland in Connecticut Schools

Connecticut wants its public schools to teach Arab and Islamic Studies. With roughly two billion Muslims, more than 50 Muslim-majority countries and territories, and fourteen centuries of civilization, there is an enormous history to explore.

Yet some advocates want the curriculum to teach children that the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 was genocide against Palestinian Arabs, part of the so-called “Nakba.” In doing so, a course about Islamic civilization risks becoming a political campaign against the Jewish state.

In March 2026, Audra King, a professor at Central Connecticut State University and member of the CSU-AAUP faculty union, urged lawmakers to include the “Nakba” in genocide education. She also called for educator unions, along with Muslim, Palestinian and Arab representatives, to participate in developing the curriculum.

Erna Alic, a Trinity College program manager whose family fled Bosnia, similarly urged Connecticut to teach the “Nakba” alongside the Bosnian genocide. That was an actual genocide, not a political smear.

The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) also advocated including the “Nakba” in Arab and Islamic Studies, as did anti-Israel groups like Jewish Voice for Peace, although it did not explicitly characterize the events of 1948 as genocide.

The testimony was submitted in support of HB 5328, which did not itself become law. Connecticut nevertheless enacted a separate provision directing the development of Arab and Islamic Studies resources.

The controversy then moved from what should be taught to who would write the lessons.

A September investigation by Connecticut Centinal, citing State Department of Education records, reported that the curriculum design team included a national CAIR consultant and four educators recommended by CAIR-Connecticut.

Proposed CT teachers for “Nakba” submitted via email from CAIR-CT’s Farhan Memon, fmemon@cair.com, (203) 517-6526

On October 7, 2023, Zareena Grewal called Israel “a murderous, genocidal settler state” and said Palestinians had “every right to resist through armed struggle.” She also wrote “It’s been such an extraordinary day!” while retweeting a video of the attack, and “Settlers are not civilians.”

While CAIR has a legitimate role in explaining Islam, and teachers’ unions have interests in representing educators, neither has special authority to determine how the history of Jewish heritage and sovereignty should be presented to Connecticut schoolchildren.

Connecticut recognizes the importance of community representation. Its antisemitism working group reserves two seats for the Jewish Federations Association of Connecticut. Yet the Arab and Islamic Studies legislation which is pushing to cover the establishment of the Jewish State provides no comparable guarantee for Jewish historians or pro-Israel educators.

“Nakba” rally on the lawn of West Hartford Town Hall. (photo: John Cappadona)

The “genocide” accusation demonstrates why that representation is essential.

In February 1947, British Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin told Parliament that Arab leaders were “opposed to the creation of a Jewish State in any part of Palestine.” Arab leaders had rejected partition in 1937 and rejected it again when the United Nations proposed Jewish and Arab states in November 1947. Meanwhile, Jewish leaders accepted the UN plan.

When Israel declared independence on May 14, 1948, armies from five neighboring Arab countries invaded the following day. Only three years after the Holocaust, Jews were fighting to defend their restored sovereignty against armies determined to prevent the Jewish state from surviving.

Meanwhile, Jordanian forces captured Jerusalem’s Old City, expelled its Jewish residents, and destroyed or desecrated synagogues. Jordan occupied and subsequently annexed eastern Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria, excluding Jews from the Western Wall and other holy sites. Its 1954 nationality law explicitly excluded Jews from a provision granting citizenship to qualifying former Palestinian nationals.

Across Arab countries and Iran, roughly 1 million Jews left over the following decades, driven by varying combinations of expulsion, persecution, violence, discriminatory laws and emigration. Israel absorbed hundreds of thousands of them. That constituent is the largest demographic in Israel today.

This was the history of the Jewish people in the years surrounding Israel’s founding: Holocaust survivors defending their independence, Jews expelled from Jerusalem, ancient communities disappearing across the Middle East, and a neighboring Arab kingdom writing Jewish exclusion into its citizenship law.

Yet advocates want Connecticut students to learn that the establishment of the Jewish state was genocide against local Palestinian Arabs. The accusation turns a defensive war for Jewish sovereignty into a supposed campaign of extermination. Teaching that accusation as established fact would substitute political propaganda for historical education.

But there is an even more basic question. Why should this particular conflict occupy such a prominent place in a course about two billion Muslims?

Islam originated in Arabia, with Mecca and Medina as its foundational holy cities. Its civilization stretches from Morocco to Indonesia, encompassing great empires, religious traditions, literature, mathematics, medicine, architecture and philosophy. the Stateless Arabs from Palestine (SAPs) represent only a small fraction of the Muslim world.

The Land of Israel, by contrast, is the birthplace and geographic heart of Judaism. Jerusalem was the capital of ancient Jewish kingdoms and home to the Jewish Temple more than a thousand years before Islam emerged. Jews have prayed toward Jerusalem and maintained their connection to the land through centuries of exile because Judaism, unlike Christianity and Islam, is an ancient land-based folk religion.

The founding of Israel belongs in the study of Judaism, not Islam.

The testimony surrounding this new Arab and Islamic coursework reveals the what some advocates want students to learn: that Israel has always been an illegal and genocidal state since its inception. It is no stretch that students will believe that anyone who supports such racist country is a racist.

CAIR has fourteen centuries of Islamic civilization to help explain. Teachers’ unions have educators to represent. Neither should turn a course about Arab and Muslim history into a campaign distorting Jewish sovereignty and vilifying Jews.

A curriculum that teaches children to call Israel’s founding a “genocide” is not teaching history. It is teaching jihadi propaganda.

Randi Weingarten’s Affordability Problem

Randi Weingarten, president of the 1.8-million-member American Federation of Teachers (AFT), was celebrating Democratic electoral victories. Her social media post praised political organizing and the role of labor unions in getting candidates elected.

There was no mention of students, reading, mathematics or educational achievement.

Weingarten’s enthusiasm makes sense. Teachers’ unions collect dues, organize voters, support political candidates and lobby elected officials. Those officials influence school budgets, employment contracts, staffing rules and teacher accountability.

The unions help elect politicians who subsequently make decisions affecting the unions’ members.

Consider four states: Connecticut, New Jersey, New York and Florida.

CTNJNYFL
Governor’s partyDDDR
Teachers in unions97.7%97.0%96.6%58.1%

The three northeast Democratic-governed states have nearly universal teachers’ union membership. Republican-governed Florida has substantially less.

What do those unions secure for their members?

Higher Pay and More Teachers

CTNJNYFL
Average teacher salary$89,593$84,974$98,655$56,663
Students per teacher11.911.811.618.4

New York teachers earn approximately 74% more than Florida teachers. New York also employs approximately 59% more teachers relative to its student population.

Some of the salary difference reflects the higher cost of living in the Northeast. But the staffing difference is substantial. New York maintains roughly 86 teachers for every 1,000 students, compared with 54 in Florida. Higher salaries and more teachers per student are attractive benefits for educators.

What Happens When the Students Leave?

Public-school enrollment has declined across much of the Northeast. New York alone lost more than 165,000 students between 2019 and 2024.

One might expect the teaching workforce to decline alongside enrollment.

Five-year changeCTNJNYFL
Student enrollment−2.9%−1.2%−6.1%~0%
Teacher staffing+1.5%+0.7%+0.5%−6.1%

New York lost 165,000 students and ADDED teachers.

Connecticut and New Jersey also increased teaching staff despite declining enrollment. Florida maintained approximately the same student enrollment while reducing teacher staffing by 6.1%.

Teachers’ unions have an obvious interest in preserving teaching positions. For taxpayers, maintaining staffing while enrollment falls can mean paying more per remaining student.

And New York taxpayers are paying considerably more.

Follow the Money

Annual spendingCTNJNYFL
Per student$26,316$27,234$31,918$12,693

New York spends $19,225 more per student every year than Florida, approximately 151% more, due to many more teachers per student and much higher salaries for teachers.

These figures include salaries, benefits, administration, transportation and other operating expenses. They exclude major capital construction and are not adjusted for regional living costs.

One might wonder whether New York is educating a much more challenging student population.

Are the Students Different?

Poverty and English-language proficiency affect educational outcomes. Schools serving disadvantaged students frequently require additional resources.

Student demographicsCTNJNYFL
English-language learners9.4%8.2%9.7%9.5%
Low-income students*41.9%36.1%57.1%~54%

New York and Florida have similar reported percentages of English-language learners and economically disadvantaged students. Meanwhile, New Jersey has lower percentages of both, which may help explain some of its stronger academic performance.

The student populations are hardly identical, but the demographic figures offer little obvious explanation for New York spending two and a half times as much as Florida.

What Do Students Get for the Money?

The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) provides standardized mathematics and reading examinations across states, allowing direct comparisons of academic performance.

Here are the 2024 results.

NAEP average scoreCTNJNYFL
4th-grade math239240234243
4th-grade reading219222215218
8th-grade math277282271267
8th-grade reading263266257253

Florida outperforms New York in both fourth-grade subjects, despite spending less than half as much per student. By eighth grade, New York pulls ahead, but only by four points in mathematics and four points in reading. New Jersey leads three of the four categories while spending approximately 15% less per student than New York.

New York spends two and a half times as much as Florida, yet its students score worse in fourth grade and only modestly better in eighth.

The Political Machine Keeps Humming

Teachers’ unions secure higher salaries, more teachers per student and job protections. They help elect politicians who approve the budgets and laws sustaining those benefits.

In New York, students leave, teachers stay, and taxpayers continue funding one of the nation’s most expensive public-school systems, with little corresponding academic advantage.

Weingarten concluded her post by promising to tackle the issues weighing on families, including “affordability.”

Perhaps she should start with the teachers’ unions. Their demands contribute to the school spending and property-tax burdens making life less affordable for the very families she claims to champion.


Sources and data notes: Teacher union membership is from the 2020–21 federal teacher survey, as reported by the Thomas B. Fordham Institute. Per-pupil spending is from the U.S. Census Bureau, FY2024. Teacher salaries are from the National Education Association, 2024–25. Enrollment and teacher staffing changes are from federal education data for fall 2019–2024. NAEP scores are from the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress. English-language learner percentages are from NCES. Student-teacher ratios refer to full-time-equivalent teachers, not classroom size.

Low-income figures use school-meal eligibility as a proxy and are drawn from different reporting periods. Florida’s approximate figure and full cross-state comparability remain to be verified before publication.

The Expulsion of Jewish History, Heritage and Lived Experience from America’s Classrooms

A quiet purge is beginning in American education. For decades, public schools relied on the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) to teach students about antisemitism, bigotry, and the Holocaust. Now the largest teachers’ unions are trying to drive the ADL out — not because antisemitism has disappeared, but because a new ideological litmus test has replaced the old moral clarity.

July 10, 2025 statement that largest teachers union in USA recommends no longer using material from the ADL

At the same time as NEA’s push to oust the ADL, New York City’s largest teachers’ union, the UFT, endorsed Democratic Socialist Zohran Mamdani to become mayor. Mamdani’s acceptance of the chant to “globalize the Intifada!” on New York City’s streets threatening Jews, was not considering disqualifying.

CAIR (Council of American Islamic Relations) celebrated the moment. The organization issued statements praising the union’s rejection of ADL and urging school districts across the country to follow suit. In their telling, removing the leading Jewish civil-rights organization from American classrooms was not a loss — it was liberation.

But liberation for whom?

What fills the void when ADL’s anti-bias programs are stripped from schools is not neutrality. It is an ideological curriculum that recasts Jewish history through the false frame of colonial theory. The Jewish people’s 3,000-year connection to the Land of Israel — recorded in scripture, archaeology, language, and tradition — is brushed aside in favor of a political slogan: Jews are Europeans; Israel is a colony; Jewish identity is whiteness in disguise.

And this falsehood is taught with absolute confidence, even though it collapses under the simplest demographic truth: most Jews in Israel are not European at all. More than half of Israeli Jews are Mizrahi — descendants of families rooted for centuries in Baghdad, Aleppo, Casablanca, Sana’a, and Tehran. Many arrived as refugees expelled from Muslim countries after 1948. But because their existence breaks the colonial narrative, it is erased.

In this rewritten history, Jews did not return home. They invaded. And Jewish children sitting in American classrooms are told, implicitly and sometimes explicitly, that their people do not come from the place their prayers face, the place their ancestors named, the place their holidays commemorate.

It gets worse.

Qatar is helping fill the hole in American education course materials. That same Qatar that bankrolls and supports the political-terrorist group Hamas that is sworn to killing Jews. The Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP) published a report that shows how Qatari materials are being mainstreamed in K-12 education.

Map of “Palestine” used by the NEA erases Israel

The shift is not academic. It is surgical.

When the ADL is expelled from the curriculum and radical Islamic materials are substituted, so is the understanding that antisemitism is a unique and ancient form of hatred. So is the recognition that Jews are a minority-minority. So is the historical memory that Jews have been indigenous to the Land of Israel since before Rome, before Islam, before Christianity. The frameworks that replace it reduce Jewish identity to a political position and Jewish history to a fabrication.

And Jewish students feel it instantly.

A seventh grader is told her family “isn’t really from Jerusalem.” A boy wearing a Star of David is treated as if he is declaring an ideology rather than a heritage. Mizrahi and Sephardi students — whose grandparents fled violence or expulsion in the Middle East — learn in school that Jews are “white Europeans.” A child is shamed for speaking Hebrew, as if language itself were an act of domination.

The classroom becomes a place where Jewish children learn that their story is not welcome. That they are frauds.

The unions pretend this is progress. They say they are freeing schools from “biased” Jewish organizations. Democratic senators circle around to defend the teachers’ unions and mock Jewish concerns. They hope no one knows that teacher unions only donate to Democratic candidates.

But the result is not balance — it is a world in which Jewish history is a political inconvenience, and Jewish identity is recast as oppression. The very institutions tasked with protecting vulnerable students are now erasing the vulnerabilities of one of the world’s smallest minorities.

A people is stripped of its past in front of its children. To its children, to create a new type of American: anti-Jewish.

This is not an argument about Israel. It is a warning about America. When unions push out the ADL and bring in organizations which openly provide material support to terrorists, they are not modernizing education. They are dismantling the guardrails that distinguished history from propaganda and identity from accusation.

This has an ugly echo.

On May 10, 1933, 40,000 people watched as students burned Jewish books in Berlin, Germany, part of the Nationalist Socialist (Nazi) Party’s campaign to eradicate Jewish thought and show its control of the intellectual and cultural landscape.

University students burn upwards of 25,000 “un-German” books in Berlin’s Opera Square. Some 40,000 people gather to hear Joseph Goebbels deliver a fiery address: “No to decadence and moral corruption!”

Today, it’s not Jewish opinions but Jewish history, heritage and lived experiences that are targeted for obliteration in America’s schools by the teachers unions. It must stop.