The Game Has Changed

I listened to two podcasts this week. Dan Senor and Mark Halperin discussed the socialist challenge to the Democratic Party. Yossi Klein Halevi and Donniel Hartman discussed Naza, a film accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza that reportedly received a standing ovation lasting nearly 25 minutes.

What struck me was how four intelligent, experienced men struggled to understand movements that no longer accepted their rules of engagement.

Halperin was puzzled that Abdul El-Sayed had not moderated his positions after the midterm elections. How could he expect to accomplish anything without building relationships and cooperating with his colleagues in Washington?

But El-Sayed and the socialist movement have a different ambition. They want to replace the Democratic establishment, not become more effective members of it. Their success is measured by how far they move the party toward their positions, rather than how many colleagues they persuade to join them on individual bills.

Halperin is waiting for El-Sayed to grow into the Democratic Party. El-Sayed wants the Democratic Party to grow into his movement.

The conversation between Halevi and Hartman revealed a similar disconnect. Both men were disturbed by the extraordinary reception for Naza. They questioned its allegations, its presentation of Hamas and the evidence used to condemn Israel’s conduct in Gaza. They approached the film as serious intellectuals, seeking to separate fact from fiction.

But why would an audience applaud for nearly 25 minutes? For anything?

Such enthusiasm is difficult to explain as a careful assessment of military evidence. The film offered something more emotionally satisfying: confirmation of a worldview in which Israel is not simply guilty of particular actions but is fundamentally illegitimate.

The most radical anti-Zionist activists have moved beyond questions of Israeli military conduct. Their accusation of genocide is not confined to the Gaza war. They portray Zionism itself as a colonial and racist enterprise, Israel’s establishment as an original act of ethnic cleansing and the subsequent history of the Jewish state as a continuing campaign against Palestinian Arabs.

Under this worldview, October 7 did not begin a war that Israel was forced to fight. It merely provided another occasion for Israel to reveal its supposedly genocidal character.

As such, no military investigation can answer an accusation that begins with the existence of the Jewish state. No ceasefire can satisfy a movement that regards Zionism itself as the crime.

This presents a particular challenge for the Shalom Hartman Institute.

Hartman has devoted decades to Jewish scholarship, education and the tradition of machloket l’shem shamayim, disagreement for the sake of heaven. Its podcast, For Heaven’s Sake, reflects the belief that serious people can examine competing arguments and emerge with greater understanding.

But that tradition presumes participants recognize one another’s legitimacy. What happens when one side considers the very existence of the Jewish state an offense that no amount of evidence can justify?

Halperin and Senor expect the socialists to learn how to operate within the Democratic Party. Halevi and Hartman expect Israel’s accusers to be persuaded by facts and reason.

They have not recognized that the game itself has changed.

Leave a Reply