Every Picture And Headline Tells A Story: Columbia’s Pro-Palestinian Students Are NOT Antisemitic

The New York Times loves to tell stories with pictures and captions alongside its articles. It has a long history of using those visuals to downplay Palestinian Arab terrorism and antisemitism, as well as to magnify Israeli violence.

The paper also does this in its backyard of New York City, where it sanitizes Palestinian supporters’ antisemitism.

Antisemitic attacks, harassment and intimidation have become rampant on college campuses and at Columbia University in NYC, in particular. Last week, the head of the university and board members were summoned to testify before congress to address the scourge that had taken over the campus. In the aftermath of that testimony where Columbia’s leaders readily acknowledged the horrible situation for Jews on campus, things actually got worse.

Chants of “there is only one solution, intifada revolution” were heard throughout the campus and surrounding streets, in calls to terrorize and slaughter Israeli Jews. There were additional calls to “globalize the intifada” to bring the massacres to diaspora Jewry.

Jews were taunted with “Go back to Poland” and “we don’t want Zionists here!” Some Hamas supporters yelled “we’re all Hamas, pig!” at Jews walking by.

The situation was so toxic, that the Orthodox rabbi at Columbia/Barnard told his community that Columbia clearly “cannot guarantee Jewish students’ safety in the face of extreme antisemitism and anarchy,” and as such, recommended that Jewish students go home and not return to campus until matters settled.

President Biden echoed the disgust in his Passover remarks stating “This blatant Antisemitism is reprehensible and dangerous – and it has absolutely no place on college campuses, or anywhere in our country.”

The appalling situation was obvious to anyone who looked at the dynamics. But not for the Times which has an agenda to minimize antisemitism which might cloud the narrative that Palestinians are the only victims in this story.

The headline ran that “some Jewish students feel targeted” with a sub-header that other Jews “rejected that view,” informing viewers in bold that the whole narrative of antisemitism among the pro-Palestinian protestors is highly questionable.

The lead image showed marchers “apparently unaffiliated with Columbia” who “reportedly shouted at Jewish students.” There are dozens of videos showing the harassment, so why add the “reportedly” to make the claim dubious?

The article continued with a picture of “a Jewish graduate student” sitting comfortably on the campus green noting “he doesn’t feel unsafe” as well as another picture of women in kafiyehs with a caption that “many of the pro-Palestinian demonstrators at Columbia are Jewish.” Clearly the Times wanted viewers to internalize that this protest could not be antisemitic, as Jews participated.

The final picture of the protestors was taken from above at night, with tents huddled together in a peaceful shot of the “Gaza Solidarity Encampment.”

For the casual/Instagram-oriented reader who just scans the headlines, pictures and captions, the story was that Arabs, Jews and others were participating in anti-war peaceful protests on campus, with some people from outside the university perhaps saying something which might be construed as antisemitic. Any actions taken by the school administration against the student demonstrators was therefore unwarranted, and pressured by the too sensitive (and too powerful) Jews.

Just to get YOUR antisemitic attitudes up a few notches.

Even as Jews were targeted for attack and fled from university life, The Times told its readers that “pro-Palestinian demonstrators” are neither pro-Hamas nor antisemitic. It’s an alt-left / jihadi marketing ploy, marketed by the “axis of resistance” of Iran-Russia-China; their proxies of Hizbullah and Hamas in the Middle East; Rashida Tlaib, Ilhan Omar and Jamaal Bowman in Congress; Students for Justice in Palestine on college campuses; and the alt-left media like The New York Times.

Know that when the alt-left demands that White people give up their privilege, they also demand that Jews give up their victim hood and rights to protection.

Related articles:

NY Times Minimizes Antisemitism While Flagging Islamophobia (November 2023)

New York Times Opinion Section Completely Fails Empathy For Slaughtered Jews With Outright Lies (October 2023)

Every Picture Tells A Story: No Brutal Slaughter Of Israeli Civilians (October 2023)

Palestine Islamic Jihad: NY Times vs. State Department (May 2023)

NY Times Does Not See Antisemitism In Texas Shooting (May 2023)

Every Picture And Headline Tells A Story: Raid On Terrorists (January 2023)

NY Times Repeatedly Tells Its Readers That An Israeli Supported A Mass Murderer, But Never That Many Palestinians Embrace Many Terrorists (December 2022)

New York Times’ Muslim Anti-Semitism Washing (October 2022)

NY Times Is Not Willfully Ignorant But Willfully Misleading About The Arab-Israeli Conflict (July 2022)

New York Times Mum on Muslim Anti-Semitism (January 2022)

Every Picture Tells a Story: Israel Is Scared of Female Iranian Shoppers (February 2021)

NY Times Considers Notion That Terrorism Against Israel is a Matter of Free Speech (January 2021)

Every Picture Tells A Story: Palestinian Terrorists are Victims (November 2020)

For The New York Times, “From the River to the Sea” Is The Chant of Jewish and Christian Zealots (May 2020)

The NY Times Will Not Write About the Preferred Violence of Palestinians (July 2019)

For The NY Times, Antisemitism Exists Because the Alt-Right is Racist and Israel is Racist (April 2019)

Every Picture Tells a Story: Anti-Semitism (February 2017)

Every Picture Tells a Story: Versions of Reality (October 2015)

Every Picture Tells a Story, the Bibi Monster (July 2014)

Every Picture Tells a Story, Don’t It? (July 2014)

3 thoughts on “Every Picture And Headline Tells A Story: Columbia’s Pro-Palestinian Students Are NOT Antisemitic

  1. I have studied all my life with the fearless and greats; Rabbis Meir and Benjamin KahaneZ”l; Rabbi Schlomo Carlebach Z”L; Rabbi Ephraim Buchwald and Rabbi Steven Riskin; and, Rabbi Schneerson ( Z”L). I have continually read Rav Kook( Z”L).

    When tragically most were afflicted, assassinated, or died young- almost back to back – we were left bereft of any meaningful Rabbinic leadership anywhere. The vacuum was even worse in Yeshivas, corrupt and misdirected endless Jewish charities and non- think tanks, and the vaunted Universities all over the world including Israel. The infinite variety betrayed or failed everyone.

    I particularly acted to curb the causeless hatred ,in all forms ,at all the Universities from which I chose to graduate: Tufts, Temple Law; Hebrew University Law. All of them increasingly offered “ anti – zionism” in one form or another ; while promoting Arabic, Russian , and Colonialist but always Anti -Jewish philosophies, sanitized histories and languages.

    when we publically challenged the faculty both Jewish and non, no one ever tried to do justice instead of threats, ostracism, and mockery. Thanks Gd, we were determined, strong, unflinching, and successful while I always graduated with honors.

    The circumstances of today were much worse back then, but there were wise- dedicated- and Jew loving allies as well as leaders. The abscence of any today, including parents to faculty to Clergy to Administrations to Democrats; is the direct cause of nationwide academic fraud and Jew hatred. As with the Aug 1991 pogrom by West Indian and Black communities and opportunists; the security, the police, the reserves, the National Guard, and all the political and social previous alleged support; fled far away. Only Assemblyman Dov Hikind, Rabbi Carlebach, Curtis Sliwa, and Kahane Chai( I participated from one to another) came both to defend and respond.

    It hasn’t been 40 years and history repeats itself as in a much larger mirror. We never grow up until all our enemies invade Israel with the most unforgivable of endless atrocities. And then, as in the exodus from Egypt, many gentiles join us while many Jews refuse to leave slavery in Egypt. The ten of the 12 Jewish heads from each tribe, why immediately tried to stone Moses and flee Gds directive to claim their earned inheritance; live on. If nothing gets smarter and retaliatory , all of us remain victims.

    Like

  2. Pingback: Why Should Columbia Protect Jews If The Government Won’t? | FirstOneThrough

  3. Pingback: At Columbia And NY Times, There’s No Jew Hatred In Antisemitism | FirstOneThrough

Leave a reply to Shannon Taylor Cancel reply